Supernatural Oneshots

Our little secret -Part 2 (Casifer)

CasiferxWinchester!Reader

Words: 2095

Song: Tag you're it -Melanie Martinez

Warning: Season 12 spoilers

Lucifer started going through your phone and you weren't brave enough to stop him. "Tell me, my lil' companion-"

"I'm not your companion."

"You just lied to Dean, more than once, and you did it for me. That looks like a fresh start of a new cooperation. So... tell me... How good liar are you?"

"Why?"

"Because I need you to lie for me again, dumbass." He walked back to you and leaned closer. He put your phone in the back pocket of your jeans, his cheek slightly touching yours. "It's not like you can say 'no' to me but I would like to make our relationship more... friendly. So I'm gonna ask questions and you'll be giving me the right answers. Let's try... So (Y/N), will you help me? Please?" He did Cas's puppy eyes and waited for yes.

"Fine..."

"Thank you!" He hugged you quickly like a little child. "Now... The plan."

"What plan?"

"Our plan, darling." Lucifer turned around and sat down on Crowley's throne. "You will go back in your hobbit hole and do whatever you usually do. And of course you'll make sure your offensively tall brothers won't find out about me. In meantime I will be doing my best to save the world and then we can have fun together. Simple, right?"

"This can't work."

"Why not?"

"Sam and Dean know Cas better than you do. You are a good actor but you can't fool them."

"And that's why I have you." His smile got bigger as he raised his hand and snapped his fingers. You appeared back in the room full of books. 

You took a chair closest to you and sat down. Your whole body shaking and weak. "I'm not gonna survive this..."

***

Boys came back from the hunt right the next day. Everytime you looked in your brother's eyes you felt guilt building up in your chest. You wanted to tell them so badly. Not just because it was the right thing to do, but also you were scared. You were in huge trouble and you were completely alone in it.

"Hey (Y/N)!"

You jumped up a little and looked at Dean who was waving his hand in front of your face.

"Is anyone there?"

Sam chuckled and then his eyes went back to his computer.

"Sorry bro... I just got lost in my mind a bit."

"Yeah, I see. Are you okay? Or are you in love?" Dean sang the last word and wiggled his eyebrows at you.

"Come on dude! With who? This book?" You hit him with old book you were holding.

"Au!" He started whining dramatically and fell on the floor. Sam was laughing so hard, he almost fell off his chair and ended up on the floor with Dean.

"If you keep acting like a little baby, I'll shoot you." Your smile was so big your cheeks hurt. Dean calmed down and got up.

"Stop both of you." Sam tried really hard to sound serious but that made all of you laugh again. "Guys! I'm serious! I found something."

"Fine, fun-ruiner, what do you got?" Dean stood up and crossed his arms on his chest.

"The hand of God."