Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios

You Make Up

REQUESTED BY @Phoenix_305

Jeff The Killer
You heard a knock at your door. You yawned, before lazily standing up from the couch. You walk over the door and opened it, to surprisingly see Jeff.

Your eyes widened as you open your mouth to say something, but close it. You looked his over. His black shaggy hair was all messy. He white hoodie was full of fresh blood. His hands to. "J-Jeff?" You asked, as he looked up at you. Even though he had a permanent smile, his eyes looked sad. He took a step in and placed his hands into your waist. "I just can't stay away from you." He growled, squeezing your hips. You bit your lip. "Jeff I'm sorr—" he smashed his lips into yours.

Once he pulled away, he stared down at you. "I forgive you. But know that if you do it again, I won't just kill the boy." He muttered.

Ben Drowned
"GRR WHAT THE FUCK!" You yell, throwing you stupid controller at the wall, instantly regretting it.

"LOOK WHAT YOU IDIOTS MADE ME DO!" You yelled. You we're playing Overwatch online and there was this one player who kept kicking your ass. They targeted you! You frowned and stood up to go get your controller. "You're so lucky its not broken." You mutter, sitting back down.

You started at your screen, pist off. "It's... frozen." You mutter. After a few seconds of a frozen screen, a message in green popped up. It read:

Please forgive me (Y/n)... I miss you.

You stared at the screen, already knowing it's Ben. You glared for a few seconds, before softening.

"Fine." You muttered. You looked down at your lap. Before you knew what was happening, you felt arms wrap around you. "You better not cheat on me again, you idiot!" I mutter. I looked up in his bleeding eyes, to see regret plastered in his face. "I won't..."

Ticci Toby
You had your face in your hands, crying. You couldn't bare living without Toby in your life. You missed him so much and you felt so bad for snapping at him.

You cried for what seemed like hours, before looking up finally. You took a deep breath, remembering what you read once. It said "some people cut to cope with strong emotions." Maybe... it would work? Maybe it would help you get over Toby.

You walked over to you desk and grabbed a pocket knife you kept, just in case. You opened it and placed that blade on your wrist. You closed your eyes tightly before starting to press down.

You felt someone grab your other wrist, stopping you from making the cut. "Y-y-you k-know... y-you shouldnt start c-cutting. It's h-hard to s-stop." You looked up to see Toby. Your eyes widened as you wrapped your arms around his neck. "Toby... I missed you." He wrapped his arms around your waist. "I-I missed y-y-you t-too."

Masky
You sigh as you picked up the phone. "Yes?" You asked, in an aggravated tone. "(Y/n)? It's Ryan!" You sigh. "Ryan... I—" he cut you off. "Before you say anything, I want to say I like you." You sigh. "Ryan. We can't be friends. I don't like you like that. Please don't call me anymore. Bye." You hung up. You brought you knees up to your chin and sigh.

"I didn't want you to do that." You looked over your window to see it opened. Your eyes widened as you felt someone wrap there arm around you. You looked over to see Masky beside you. You tackled him to the ground, straddling him.

"Masky! I missed you sooo much!" You said, ripping his mask off and smashing your lips onto his. He placed his hands in your hips as you pulled away. "I'm sorry for forgetting about our date it's just that I used to only have one friend and now everyone wants to be my friend and it's—" he cut you off. "I'm sorry for snapping at you, babe." You smiled down at him, as he grinned back up at you. You stared into each other's eyes, before he smashed his lips onto yours, again.

Hoodie
It was a routine for you now. Everyday you would walk to the abandoned park to be alone, and sad. But today was different.

When you got there, someone was sitting in Hoodies swing. That was the swing you would sit in. You frowned, before your eyes widened. That person looked familiar. They had a orange coloured hoodie and a black mask.

"Hoodie...?!" You whispered. He looked up from the swing, spotting you instantly. The two of you looked at each other, before you ran over. You tackled him, making him fall backwards off the swing, you on top of him. "Please forgive me Hoodie. I didn't tell you were I went because I was worried you would be worried. Because my dad hit me so I ran off..." you mumbled. He placed his gloved hand on your cheek. "(Y-Y/n)..." he whispered. "It's fine. I-Im s-sorry for over r-reacting. ...wait. Your father beats you?!" He muttered, angrily. He softly pushed you off him, before cracking his knuckles.

"Hoodie don't—" you grabbed his hand. He slid his mask up, revealing his beautiful dark brown eyes. "I h-have to... he hurt you and I... I l-l-love you..." you stood in front of him. "Hoodie... not now. I missed you." You mumbled, hugging him.

Lost Silver

You we're sobbing loudly. Good thing your treehouse was in the middle of the forest, cause if not, you were sure the world would've heard you.

You opened you Ds, and turned on Pokemon. You couldn't take it anymore. You missed Silver so badly. You hardly ate, or slept and you got more depressed then you already were. You need him, or you'll die. Okay, you probably won't die, but you'll die on the inside.

You sobbed as the game turned on. You pushed yourself in a corner, bringing your knees up to your chin. You placed your head into your knees and sigh.

You watched as Silver crawled out of the Ds and practically jumped you. His arms were wrapped around your neck, as you nuzzled in the  crook of his neck.

"Silver. Don't leave me anymore....." you whispered. He pulled away from you a little, looking into your eyes. "I won't, I promise."

Homicidal Liu & Sully

You we're alone in your room. A bottle in your hand and the tv remote in your other. You we're slowly becoming an alcoholic. You turned the tv on and out on (ur fav show).

You opened the bottle and placed your lips against it. As you tipped it up, you felt someone grab it from you hands. "Hey! What the... fuck?" You stared into Liu's eyes.

"Liu. Sully??? What The fuck give me my bottle back." You frowned, as he nodded. "(Y/n) I'm soo sorry for cheating on you. It ment nothing."

You frown at him, before smiling a little. "Fine. You're forgiven. But I hope you know I had to get a new bed." He looked away. "Yeah sorry about that." He looked back over to you, just as you pressed your lips onto his.

(A/N: ohhhh! Hoodie was the first to tell you that he loved you. How unexpectedly adorable. XD I HOPE YOU ENJOYD THIS I FANGIRLED WHILE WRITING THIS CHAP! :3 sooo yeah. Pls vote and comment cause I'm trash. 🔫🔫 *watergun emoji wtf*)