Buttontale (Child!Reader Insert)

Chapter 3 - Other Brother

(Sorry it's been a while, I've been focused on PJ's Daycare)

It was pouring rain outside.  Making it all creepy that it's night. "Oh! For my twitching itchy siblings. I give you bowls of porridge and I give you bowls of rice." A spoon of what looked like slime was placed on my plate. "Ewww!" I shouted shoving the plate away. "It looks like slime." Blueberry said lifting a spoonful up. "It's slime or bedtime." Papyrus said eating some of the grossness. "Do you think he's trying to poison us?" Blue asked staring at me. I learned back in the chair.

I was laying in bed wearing my green pajamas. My room wasn't that special though. I placed my stuffed animal on my bed. I look over at the doll. "Goodnight.... Me." I close my eyes and fall asleep.

I woke up hearing tiny squeaks. I open my eyes slowly. I sit up and look around. I looked under the bed. I saw a white mouse. I got out of bed and chased after the mouse. I open up the door. The mouse was near the stare case. I ran down the stairs chasing it into the living room.  It was missing. I looked around and saw it come from under the sofa. The mouse ran into the door. "Heh. I got you know mouse!" I cheered. I open the door a little bit looking down. It wasn't there. I saw a flash of blue and opened the door wider. There was a tunnel. "Y/N? Did you see the mouse too?" I heard Blue from behind me. I moved out the way for him go see. "Wow!" Blue started crawling in, I followed. I couldn't see what's in front of Blue though. He got out and I heard him grown. I got out as well. It was our living room! Blue went to look at the picture if the human boy who spilled his ice cream. "Blue!? Do you smell that!" I jogged to the kitchen. "Papyrus?" I cocked my head. "What are you doing in the middle of the n-" I paused as I saw Papyrus's eyes. They were buttons. "You're not our brother, you have B-" Blue paused. "B-B-B-Buttons? You see you two, I'm your other brother silly. Now go tell your father supper is ready." Blue stared at Other Papyrus confused. "But our father is dead." Blue looked down. "Well here he isn't." Papyrus said. I nodded and followed Blue holding his hand. "He's in the study!" We entered a room. "H-Hello." I said shyly to our Other Father. "Hey you two. Want to hear a song?" "Our father never played piano." Blue said confused. "Don't need to." White gloves reached out to us. I stared at them between Blue's arm. "This piano plays me." Dad said. He finished and Blue tapped him. "He said to tell you the food's ready." Blue said. "Who's starving, raise your hand." Dad said. The gloves raised his arm. I smiled a bit.

Me and Blue sat at one end. I was leaning close, this is all weird. Dad and Papyrus were praying? Papyrus smiled. I took a piece of the turkey. Blue did the same, it was closest to us. I took a bite. "This is really good!" I said chewing looking at Blue. You both are hungry, aren't you?" Papyrus asked. "Do you have gravy?" Blue asked. I was eating corn on the cob. It was really yummy. "Here comes the gravy train choo-choo!" Papyrus laughed. The train poured brown gravy on Blue's mashed potatoes. "Would you like some bread rolls?" I grabbed one. "Sweet peas?" "No thanks." Me and Blue said kindly. "Have any drinks? I'm thirsty." Blue asked. "Of course." Dad said, should I even call him that. I'm gonna say Gaster. I look up, the chandeliers had drinks on them. "Mango Milkshake?" Blue asked. "Oh! Oh! Can I have (Favorite Drink)!" Blue drunk some of his milkshake. I poured mine in. A cake was placed in front of us. It was chocolate with strawberry frosting. Writing was being written on it, 'Welcome Home' it said. I looked up at them. "I think we should be going to bed." Blue stood up. "Tired? We have a room for the both of you."

Blue and I laid in the same bed. Yeah, I would rather be with him than being alone. It was weird here. I held his arm.

"Sweet dreams."