In love with the popular one ON HOLD

Next level (Chapter 5)

Lemon Alert! Some lemon!

Their thoughts about the past 2 weeks

Natsu POV

It's been half a month. Half a month since Alexis came back. Half a month since sting and Lucy started dating. Half a month since I've realized I had loved Luce. And half a month since my heart broke in two.
Lucy gives me sad looks every time I see her now, since she had learned the truth about me and Alexis. But she didn't care she just went on to sting without a single thought, that's how I know she doesn't feel the same way.

Lucy POV
It's been two weeks. Two weeks Alexis came. Two weeks since I decided to hide away my feeling and date sting. Three weeks since I've realized I had loved Natsu. And Two weeks since my heart broke in half.
I see Natsu looking really happy with Alexis. We don't communicate but he glances at me now and then. I had started to date sting so I could rid of my feelings for Natsu. I was just a new toy to replace the old one that he had lost, now the old one had shown up again. He doesn't pay attention to me at the least, that's how I know he doesn't feel the same way.

Normal (still half a month since)

Natsu POV

I see sting and Lucy go to each other's houses all the time! I'm sure they had done it by now..... I felt so empty and useless. -ring- that's the lunch bell! Sweet food! "Hey Natsu, I wanna talk to u for a sec." a voice says behind me. I turn around to see Alexis looking at me "uh,sure" I reply "ok, follow me!" She says pulling my hand leading me to a private spot behind the school. "So we have been dating for a couple years now and we'll my parents are not home tonight. So I was wondering if u would like to come over to um, yeah" she said. I feel like I'm betraying Lucy some how when I say this but I know she already has someone "yeah! That will be great! I'll meet I at your house I guess!" I say sounding exited but I'm not honestly . I feel a little bad for doing this just to hide my feeling for Lucy.... but it's not like I haven't done it before! But that was Before I met her..... whatever!

At her house

I ring the door bell and hear foot steps nearing the door. Her house is pretty big honestly! But I like little houses like Lucy's...... "hey come in!" Alexis says as she opens the door. I walk in and she shuts it behind me. "Go get unchanged my room is third one to the left upstairs!" She says winking as she leaves somewhere. I walk up and wait about ten min. Till she comes in with a sexy lingerie. I bet it would look better on Lucy tho..... was my only thought as she climbed on top of me

A couple days later

Lucy POV
It was April 1st and
Sting was absent today....... and it's lunch time now "hey Luce! Long time no see!" A voice calls ahead of me. I see Natsu waving at me and smiling "uh, hi, watcha want?" I reply awkwardly "Wanna eat lunch with me?" He says "yeah!" I say a little too exited. He laughs at my excitement and I blush in embarrassment . We get to the table where I used to sit in the good days and sit down. "Hey n-nastu" Alexis says looking at nastu "yes?" He replied "I- I'm p-p-p-pregnant" she stutters. My heart stopped. I felt sick, really sick. My heart is now shattered. I could feel my eyes getting watery and blurry. I stood up and ran. Ran as fast as I could to the nearest park and cried my eyes out. I thought I was over him, but I thought wrong I felt like I could cry for days....

Nastu POV

That one sentence...... it made my heart stop I look over to Lucy to see her pale and tears in her eyes. She had no emotion on her face. She stood up and ran fast. I wish I could have too. I don't know why she did, she doesn't love me does she? I felt sick and my stomach dropped "HAHA LOOK AT YOUR FACE!!!" Alexis yelled. What? Why was this funny?! "APRIL FOOLS! Gotcha!" She screamed "that wasn't funny." I said while running after Lucy. I stopped mid-way and said "we're done btw" I think I got a little too angry but I meant what I said! "Your joking right? Right?!" Was the last thing I heard when I exited the building.... I went to the nearest park cus I know that Lucy had a thing with parks when she's upset. There she is..... "Luce?" I say as I squat down next to her she seemed a little surprised and jumped... I think I scared her I laugh to myself. "What?" She says whipping away her tears putting on a fake smile. "Y r u upset?" I ask sincerely "Natsu........... I-i love u!" She screamed. What?! She loves me? "Luce I-" I started till she cut me off "I loved u and u used me! I was just another replacement for your lost girlfriend! I tried to fall deep
In love with sting! And forget about u! But I couldn't!" She said " you had me fall for u! Then someone comes and you not only ignore me! But u made my heart break!" "Now y don't u go to your pregnant little girlfriend and leave me be! Nothing will change if u do!" She said finishing her outburst "its April fools day you know.... she was joking" I started to feel my heart get put back together. "I broke up with her..........  that was not a joke." I said "what do y-" Lucy started till I put my finger on her lips "I'm not done yet" I say softly "i thought you loved sting... I tried to hide my feeling behind her.... Lucy I love you!" I say her eyes start to tear up again "she is my PAST, you are my FUTURE" I say those being my last words before kissing her. She kissed back and melted into the kiss " let's go home" I say "o-ok" Lucy says. We get to the house and go to my room then close the door. As soon as it closed I pinned Lucy against it and started to kiss her softly. The kiss became very more rough and passionate. I put me hand under her shirt and bra and massage her breasts. She moans. And I slip them both over her head. She then takes off my shirt. "I'm glad you'll be my first" she breaths out. "Wait you've never done it?!" I say confused mixed with excitement! "No" she says "ok then I'll make your first time special" I say finally. Lucy is now completely naked me in just my boxers but she takes care of that. I bring her to the bed and lay her down. Me on top of her. I go down to her entrance and lick her cilt causing her to moan. I stick a finger inside her then stick 2 more. She was trying to keep in her moans and it was working! Nope that's not gonna work for me. I take out my fingers and get my member inside her. She was now a moaning mess. Success!

Soooooo well um, that happened....

Tell me if your enjoying the story I guess?

I do not own fairy tail btw!

Till  next time

~Paige