Capricorn: Sally
Aquarius: Laughing Jack
Pisces: Jeff The Killer
Aries: Kate The Chaser
Taurus: Hoodie
Gimini: Laughing Jill
Cancer: The Puppeteer
Leo: Jane The Killer
Virgo: Maskey
Libra: Slenderman
Scorpio: Nurse Ann
Sagitarius: Splenderman