Angelica X Female!Reader-More Than Friends?

101 5 4
                                    

Requested from ameuana_aphasia
"Can you do an Angelica x reader where reader is Maria's sister and she asks angelica for help."
A/N- ;-; I love a good angst.. ps I'm really proud of that edit even though it sucks😂
Also changed the plot a little bit, instead of asking for help she confront (Y/N) about the Reynolds Pamphlet, if you want me to change it please let me know!

🥀
Notes- Unhappy endings, satisfied references, Hamiltime, female pronouns, girl x girl (obviously), suicide
🥀

I had been sitting in the kitchen reading a book, Common Sense, by Thomas Paine. My friend had recommended it to me, well more like love interest.

Angelica Schuyler.

When I had met her at the market, I forgot my dang name, I know it's wrong to be in love with another women. It would be considered utterly disgraceful, and the already dreaded Reynolds name would be buried in even more hatred.
( it's kinda sad how almost 300 years later some people are still in that situation)

There was nothing I could do about it, except bite my tongue every time I thought about confessing. Love like that is so rare...right?
To be be with someone you actually love? Maria had recently been courting someone, she said he was abusive, I tried to get her out of that relationship but she said she had it 'covered' whatever that meant.

I sighed all this is too much, tears pricking my eyes. My thoughts had been interrupted by a harsh knock at the door, great another visitor, this had been the 7th one that hour!

The Reynolds name had always been associated with cheating and crookery, so this wasn't anything new. Though it was usually in much smaller quantity, maybe angry yelling every once in a while. Threatening to expose my 'secrets' whatever that meant. I was going to ignore it again till I heard

"HOW COULD YOU DO THIS TO ME!"

That was Angelica, did I do something? I tried to think of the last time I met with her, had I said anything?

"Open the door, and stop being a coward" her voice wavering, she was crying, this was bad.

Really bad.

I walked over to the door and opened it hesitantly, I didn't not want to see what I did.

Angelica, eyes red and puffy, hands on hips staring at me like I was a piece of trash, a look I was all too familiar with. She pushed me aside and came in, I quickly closed the door behind her, whatever was going on the world did not need to hear, little did I know the world already knew.

"Do you know what this is?" She said bitterly shoving a pamphlet in my hands, it had in bold letters 'The Reynolds Pamphlet'

"No, this couldn't have been what she was talking about" flipping trough the pages, she did this?!? Just to get out of her courtship??

"You knew she was doing this?!"
"Well no.."
"(Y/N), that was my damn sister he cheated on because of your family"

There it was the 'your family' comment, Angelica was the only one who never tied me to my family name, who let me be my own person beyond (Y/N) Reynolds.

"..."
Tears were rolling down my cheeks, she shoved me, "You don't get to cry" she didn't stop there, she didn't hurt me physically the rest of the day, how I wish she would, her words were far more painful.

"I trusted you, my family warned me 'don't make friends with a Reynold they'll cheat you and beat you' I didn't pay a damn mind. You were an amazing friend, another intellectual mind, someone I could talk to and connect with" her tone getting softer as the ramble went on

"I fell in love with you"

My heart stopped, but she went on, piercing my heart with every word

"I didn't know how to deal with my feelings!" Began walking back and forth no longer being able to make eye contact with me.
"I hid them, I was going to confess but then didn't, why would you love me"

"Then I find this, a Reynolds breaking my sisters heart and I found out everything my family said about you people is true" she turned looking me dead in the eyes, she crouched down to get on my level.

"I still love you, and it's wro-"

Without thinking I smashed my lips on to hers, still on cloud 9 that she shared the same feeling
(Say no to this just came on lol) not thinking about what my sister did might affect how she felt about me.

We kissed, it was amazing. I never felt this way about any man who I had been out on evenings with. If felt so right, she pulled back her eyes wide in horror.

"NO!"
"Why can't you understand, this. is. wrong."
"Your going to break my heart, your a Reynolds, I can't, I can't, I...just...can't"
Breaking down into sobs once again.

I scrambled to hugged her, until she slowly quieted down, and hugged back. What seemed all too soon she pulled back, "This isn't right!"

"Your going to use me for money, or to ruin the Schuyler name"

"No Angie, I would never thi-"
"You don't get to call me Angie!"
"Angelica, you have to understand I'm not my family!"
"Save it"

She got up dusted herself off, "I just can here to tell you don't ever try to contact me again."

With that comment she turned and left, slamming the door, little did Angelica know she would regret that decision for the rest of her days.

Why?

You hung yourself the next day.

🥀
That was sad, damn who knew I could be so depressing?

✱Musical OneShots/Imagines (xReader)✱Where stories live. Discover now