Eyeless Jack: You were petrified. You were talking to a man who got lost when Jack just lost it. Only than did you remember that he wasn't human. He was a monster. You flinched from him and avoided him the best you could after that.
Bloody Painter: You truly were scared. You were talking to a close friend of yours when Helen just killed him. It scared you. It made you think. This wasn't your Helen anymore. This was a monster. You lost trust in him.
Puppeteer: You were looking at some things when you found something... odd. It was you as a human. But... It looked like he was stalking you. You flipped through every thing realizing he lied. You weren't married... he had kidnaped you. He had raped you. He was a monster.
Nathan The Nobody: You were watching the news when Nathan got home... but... There was a girl next to him... she was much prettier than you... she was constantly flirting with him... He was ignoring you for her... it hurt... but what hurt the most is when he yelled at you for being a so called distraction... It broke your heart... (YOU ARE ALL BEAUTIFUL!!!)
Masky: You had found a mask on his end table. When you asked him about it he yelled at you... and hit you... You had ran and hid from him crying... this isn't Tim... He promised he would never hurt you... he promised...
Hoodie: Hoodie had eaten all your cookies! He promised he wouldn't eat them! Why hoodie!
Ticci Toby: He has never lied to you. If he hurts you he apologizes so many times. He has never lost your trust.