A Beautiful Nightmare- a Markiplier x Darkiplier x reader story

The Mystery Man

When the video started playing, it was the man who was in my room the night before. Except this time, I could actually see his entire face.
It's Dark, one of Mark's personas when he's feeling "evil".
But something about him felt all too real. It didn't seem like it was Mark playing a joke on his viewers with his different personalities.

Could they be actual people?
They can't be.

During the video, Dark just kept repeating how many hours I had left before I had to decide.
How am I gonna tell Vince about this?
I decided to cross that bridge when I get to it.
"It seems like your mind has made a decision, but your heart is torn." The voice sounded like it was behind me in my office. I look at the computer screen to see Dark had disappeared and I quickly turned around to find him standing in the middle of the room with his arms crossed.
"I know who you are." I say as I stand to confront him face to face.
"Well that ruins part of the mystery and some of the fun for me." He looks down at me with a smirk since I'm not that tall.
"Dark, you know my choice but what about Vince? No matter what he won't let me leave. If you've watched me for so long you must know that much."
"Don't worry about him, I'll take care of him myself. Nothing a demon can't fix."
"Promise me that you won't hurt him unless it's your last resort. I still love him after all."
"When we leave this place, you'll be joined by someone you may already know. You'll have to learn to love someone other than that abusive asshole you call a boyfriend."
"He wasn't always like this before we lived together. It's different now."
"Well, after tonight things will be different. You will be my slave and do as I say if you don't want to be hurt like what he has done to you. If you trust me, I will take care of you. I can't stand to see a perfect human being like yourself get abused any longer."
"You don't have to do this."
"But I do. Now, come with me and I'll show you your new home. I'll come back tonight to deal with him. Don't worry about your things, everything will be like you never even left this home to begin with."
Dark pulls me close to him with an arm around my waist.
"Hang on tight, cupcake." He says as the room starts spinning faster and faster. Dark looks down and gives me a concerning look. I must've looked worse than I felt. Dark takes his hand pulling my chin up so our eyes would meet.
"It's going to be alright." He says as he pulls me in closer for a kiss. More sparks were felt than ever before, and I knew Dark could feel them too by the way he didn't want to pull away.

The spinning stopped before we pulled away and the room looks like it was before, yet almost as if it was darker toned than my original room. Well, this is the house of a demon after all.
That afternoon I try and get comfortable in the new version of my own home I'll be staying in. I relax for a while on the bed when Dark comes in without a knock.
"I'm gonna head back to your place to take care of Vince. Don't worry, I won't hurt him unless I have to." Of course he knew I'd be worried about him hurting Vince. "Is there anything you need or want from your old place while I'm there? Anything that I missed and don't have here?"
"Actually, there's a black and orange hat that he gave me when we first started dating. It should be in his room by the door. I remember putting it in there when we moved in together since he got it while he was in New York. There's also a gold necklace he got me for our 6 month anniversary that fell the day before Valentine's Day, it means so much to me and I'd love it if you could grab it while you're there. It should be hanging on a small hook above my bedside table next to the mirror. I'd do anything for you to get those things back for me."
"I'll see if I can find them. Before I leave, there are rules. Don't leave this house without me at any time, and also don't go down into the basement. No matter what. Understood?"
I nod my head very confused by these rules.
"Alright, I'll be back soon." Dark says as he walks towards me and pulls me off the bed to stand close to him.
"Be careful."
"Don't worry about me." He pulls me close for one last kiss before he pulls away and disappears.

Please don't let anyone get hurt..