Bad Boy // A Jesse Underhill Fan Fic

Part 3

Once I get home I shoved all my bags onto my bed and start looking through them. Even though I was only going over for a few minutes I still wanted to make an impression. My mom has always told me that someone's first impression of me is what sticks. I end up just getting out a baby pink shirt with an open back, paired with white pants and white heels. I make sure my makeup still look presentable, and change my lipstick to a soft pink. I look in the mirror and I smile a little bit. 'Wow you actually look decent for once'. I think to myself as I go to grab my phone. I text Levi letting him know I was coming over and that I have Starbucks for him. I go onto Instagram to post a picture of my outfit tonight, and then SC to respond to people while I wait for Levi to text me saying it is okay to come over. After about 10 minutes he responds saying he excited for me to meet everyone. 'Who am I even meeting...This boy is so weird but I dig it'. I go to my parents bedroom to let them know I am leaving but I see that they both are already asleep. I close their door and realize that it is only 9:00pm. I take a deep breathe, grab Levi's coffee and head over. I knock on his door and start overthinking everything. Whoever these people are, I am positive they will not like me. The door swings open and I look up to a smiling Levi.
"Natasha! I'm so glad you came. Oh my god, is that coffee?! You are a goddess, thank you! I needed this. Oh yeah, come in." He laughs while drinking the coffee and gesturing me to come inside. I walk inside and wait for him to close the door. I realize that there are a few coats and shoes around.
"Is there a lot of people here? I don't want to ruin your time with your friends, maybe I can come back another time?" I rush out after realizing he probably didn't want me here.
He looks at me oddly "Natasha it's totally okay, I invited you here. It's just my family, my friends were not able to make it. I actually invited you because I have a brother around your age, or at least I think. You look 17.. I should have asked. But anyway I wanted you to meet them all."
"I'm actually turning 18 in 2 months. Your brother is Jesse right? Sorry, I kinda looked up your social media after we met and I found his. He seems like a cool guy, but just not what I'm into." I say while freaking out a bit.
"Oh well that's fine! At least you aren't trying to use my brother for fame. I am kinda protective over him, I love him you know? I want the best for him. Anyway they're probably waiting let's go..." he trails off as I see a women come toward us.
"Hi I am Levi's mom, you must be Natasha? His next door neighbor if I'm correct?"
"Oh yes, Hi it is nice to meet you. I was actually just about to go, I didn't realize he had family over."
She laughs while glaring at Levi "What did you tell this poor child? Come in dear, do you like cheesecake? We have a lot left over. I insist!"
She does not leave room for any discussion and starts walking to what I assume is the Living Room. I look over at Levi and he just shakes his head smiling and gestures for me to follow her. I start walking and look over at the couches. All eyes are now on me, and I hear a girl gasp.
"Nat- Nata- Natasha Young?!"
I look over at the girl and can't believe my eyes.
"Rachel! I can't believe I am meeting you... Wait you're last name is Underhill?! Why haven't you ever told me! I could have met you sooner you derp."
"I am assuming you know about Jesse... When I first met you I didn't want you to only talk to me because of my last name and who my brothers were. I wanted you to talk to me because you wanted to." she says while turning slightly red.
I smile really big and whisper "No offense, but I didn't really know who the fuck your brothers were until I ran into Levi when I first moved in."
She giggles and hugs me. I feel so happy knowing that Rachel is here, and I have met her.
She gasps again saying "We have to SnapChat this!"
I quickly take a picture and look at Levi smiling. I soon turn red realizing that I forgot about everyone. I smile at everyone and realize that they're are 2 twins that look super adorable and like they would be fun to talk to. I see Levi's mom, and I assume the man sitting next to her is his father. I look next to where Rachel was sitting and lock eyes with who I think is Jesse.... 'Holy shit, pictures do not do him justice. I would smash that' I think as he stands up. I quickly check him out and realize that he has a really good taste in fashion.
"Natasha this is my family. That is Isaac and Aaron, my mom and dad, and I assume you have already met Rachel, and lastly my brother Jesse." Levi says as he points at everyone.
"Who are you?" Jesse points out without saying anything else.
"Jesse! Be nice to her. Wait, you're last name is Young? You aren't by chance related to Christopher and Natalie Young are you?" Rachel's father asks.
I feel a bit flustered and shakily say "Yes sadly I am related to them. Wait how do you know them?"
Their father laughs a bit and says "Your father owns one of the biggest windmill companies in the NW and your mom is a high end lawyer. I do spend a little time on Facebook."
"She's probably using us for fame Levi" Jesse says.
I just look at Rachel and shake my head. 'What is his deal...'
"I mean why wouldn't you use us, I have never heard of you. So are you looking for followers or fame?"
I start to get a little pissed "Oh that's what Rachel has always wanted me on live.ly..."
Jesse just looks at me and leaves the room. It takes me a moment but I realize that I haven't heard of any big musically stars living over here.
I look at his family "He thinks I want attention doesn't he?"
His mom looks disapointed "I am so sorry he's acting like this, I apologize for his behavior."
"No no it's okay, if I was him I would look at me the same way. I have to go home, but Levi or Rachel, can you give Jesse my number? I want him to know I am not a threat. I have no reason to become famous... It was nice meeting you all." I say as I start to make my way to the door. 'So much for smashing...What an asshole, poor Rachel has to put up with him.'
"Hey hold on, wait a second. I didn't mean to sound like a complete asshole back there. Can we restart... My name is Jesse Underhill and I wanna be famous" Jesse says while smirking
"Well Jesse Underhill, I'm Natasha Young and I wanna be famous too." I reply while giggling. "You know I thought you were hella cute before you opened your mouth back there. But now... Well you're kinda cute just dumb"
"I know I'm not cute, Natasha... Sweetheart... we both know that I am so much more than that." Jesse looks at me straight in the eye as he slowly walks towards me. I start to back up because I can't think with him this close to me... Because he's right, he is so much more than that.
"I...I don't know what you mean" I stutter as I hit the wall. He puts one hand on each side of me, and I can feel my chest moving up and down. He moves his head down so I can slightly feel his lips on my ear.
"Don't make this a game princessa."
I slowly breathe and take my time answering "What if I want to?"
"Then just know I will win" I feel him lightly put his nose against my neck. "Until next time, Natasha."
I feel him put a piece of paper in my hand, and back away. I run to the door, and close it. I rush into my apartment and slam my bedroom door shut. I lean against it and let out a breathe I had been holding. I look down at the piece of paper and realize it's his number. 'What a cocky bastard' I think angrily as I touch my neck. I can't believe that I let him get that close to me, and I can't believe that I actually enjoyed it. I decide to just throw away his number and get into bed. I turn red as I touch my ear. I get into the shower, and scrub my neck. I get out and as I am about to go into my room, my phone vibrates with a text. I look down and almost choke.

Unknown Number: I had a feeling you would end up throwing my number away, so I took yours from Levi's phone sweetheart.

You: Stalkerish much Jesse?

Unknown Number: Don't think of it as stalking, think of it as... being interested.

You: Hahaha you interested? What if I'm not interested in you??

Unknown Number: I said don't start with games Natasha.

You: Oops, guess I just did. Goodnight stalker.

Unknown Number: Fine, if that's how you want to play... Goodnight Princessa.

I turn red by that last text. 'What could he mean by that... But it's hot when he speaks spanish (I know he can't speak spanish.... like at all, but let's just pretend. After all this is fan FICTION. Okay back to the story) I need to get my focus off of him, he's way to cocky.' I think as I climb into bed. This is gonna be a long ass night...