Who's the father; A Spoby Love Story

Chapter One ; A mistake

Spencer Hastings POV

I woke the next morning after telling Toby the news. He was extra excited knowing he was the "father". Toby rolled over in the bed and planted a kiss on my lips. I smiled and he chuckled. "Soon we'll be kissing as parents not just lovers." He said, I laughed and I looked into his big blue eyes. What if Caleb is the father , What would I tell Toby?

I grabbed a muffin and was out the door headed for work. How am I going to tell Hanna her husband and sons father could also be my baby's dad? I drove to work debating what to tell Hanna and the girls later when we meet at the Grille for dinner.

The work day flew by fast , dreading the conversations that I would be having later on.
As I walked to the grille and sat down at a table for 5 I waited for the other girls to arrive. A hostess brought over the other guests and we ordered drinks. "Guys, I have big news." I said, "I'm pregnant!"
"Congratulations !" The girls said all shell shocked.
"Who's the father?" Aria asked. And with that comment I went quiet.
"I don't know." I said. They all looked at me. "Either Toby or Caleb."
Hanna looked at me angrily, "you slept with my husband! YOU BITCH!" She stormed out , raising alarms in my head.

What had I done.

I had ruined a friendship because of a slip up I had with a man.
In fact I don't even know who the father is and I can see me and Toby's relationship falling to bits.

All I could think of on the way home was the consequences I'm going to have to face.

I entered my house and threw the keys on the side Toby was sprawled on the sofa. I walked up to him and kissed his cheek . He chuckled and I settled in close to his body. I could feel the heat bouncing off of him. He stroked my hair and kissed my head. I turned around and looked into his eyes. They were beautiful, he was beautiful. I drew my finger across his jawline and leaned in . He kissed me, I kissed back and felt our connection spark. He picked me up and kept kissing.he carried me up into our bedroom. He laid me on the bed and kissed my neck I moaned , he pulled away. And started moving his hands up my body, he got to my shirt and started pulling it off my head. He flung it on the floor and stared at my chest. I grinned.

"Why didn't you tell me the baby's father was Caleb , I thought you loved me!" Toby complained, I felt the sadness in his voice as it cracked saying the word love. I looked into his eyes. They weren't blue but brown. The disappointment had faded the colour. I leaned in the kiss him but he moved away. Nothing can fix this now. I had ruined our relationship.

I woke up sweating , breathless I panted . Toby was fast asleep. It was nothing but a dream. Will he really hate me if its Calebs baby?

I got up and put some sweats and a t shirt on . It was a Saturday so I didn't have work. I checked the time on my phone, 4:37am. I walked down the stairs and made a bowl of cereal I could already tell today is going to be a long day.

2 hours later...
          

"Spence , where are you ?" Toby called out. I smiled hearing his croaky morning voice.
"Downstairs, do you want some toast?" I asked .
"No , I'm fine but thank you." His politeness was to die for. I heard the shower running so decided to go upstairs waiting for Toby to get out. I lay on the bed knowing now is the time to tell him how I screwed up.

The shower stopped and I hear Toby get out. I smiled and he kissed me , I kissed back but seconds later I pulled away.
"Toby, I don't know who the father is." I said , he looked at me upset but not mad.
"Wait who do you think it could be?" He asked, looking deeply in my eyes. I couldn't help but look at his blue eyes that had started to water.

"Caleb."

"Hey sfence , arrreee yooouuu avalibleee ?" Caleb asked.
"Yes ." I replied. Caleb lunged at me kissing my neck and grabbing my hips. He pulled away and stared at my lips. Our lips connected and moved slowly but passionately in time together. I grabbed his shirt and pulled it off his head. I kissed his chest making my way down to his belt buckle. I grinned and he unbuckled it and let his pants fall to the ground. He kissed me again  and I kissed back . He pulled my shirt off  over my head and I kissed his lips biting his bottom lip and we pulled away and he looked at my pants. I chuckled and unzipped them . Letting my pants fall to the ground. We looked at each other. In underwear . Smiling. Caleb picked me up and carried me to his room . He put me down on his bed were I lay on top of him kissing his neck and chest . I pulled at his boxers and let them snap back on his waist. We both grinned.

I woke up he next day with a banging headache was that hookup the night before real. I picked up the sheets and looked down to see not just my body naked but Calebs.

"And that's how Caleb might have gotten me pregnant, I'm now proud of it but the way."  I said, looking at his face. His smile that was placed there an hour ago had dropped and formed a frown.

"Well we are going to have to find out who the father is ." He said looking at my eyes. "Sooner rather than later."

His blue eyes were now a dark shade of brown.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A/N

Word count: 1010

   I hoped you like chapter one , remember to follow me and vote for this story.
Trust me there is so much more to come!