Chances are Taken Creepypastas x Reader

Unexpected visit

"No {Name}! I would never think of you as stupid!" You chuckled and bumped him with your shoulder playfully

"You better not or I might just have to find a way to show it to you" You winked at him, making him shiver and blush

"Yo, Tobes and beast you two done with your flirting?" BEN said with a cocky smirk

"We weren't-"

"Aw what's wrong elf~? You're not jealous are you?"

"Stop it with the elf jokes! Damn Jeff and his damn mouth"

"What with me Midget elf?!" Jeff said from his place next to Toby

"You heard me!"

"SO!" you interrupted "Did you guys hear? A group of cpss's are visiting right now" Both of them scoffed at this

"Yeah those cowards are here to 'inspect' that everything is according to regulations." Jeff crossed his arms

"In other words they're just here to check that smiley ass over there isn't doing whatever he wants"

"What was that midget elf?!" The sound the mess hall's doors opening left a dead silence throughout the room.

"Well speak of the devils..." Jeff said as he glared behind him, you followed his gaze but as soon as you saw them you quickly turned to face your now empty plate and lowered your head. Toby noticed this and felt something was wrong so he began to worry, it was rare to see you with a grim expression such as this one not even at expeditions did you show such a thing.

The hall slowly started to revert to its previous state of idly chatter while you keep your head down as if hiding yourself. Toby looked around him but everyone just kept shrugging their shoulders at his pleading look which left him with no other choice but to confront you himself.

"Hey {Name} are you ok?" You nodded your head but wouldn't look up

"Are you sure?"

"{Name}?" You visibly flinched

Standing behind you was...