Chances are Taken Creepypastas x Reader

WE ARE EVEN

~~Extended ending~~

You and Toby walked back into the dining room hand in hand, which caught the attention of most of your comrades that started to whisper amongst themselves.

"Ugh! Is seeing us together that big of a deal?" Toby blushed a light pink and smiled

"Well one of the strongest soldiers holding hands with one of slender-mans proxies like me, is an odd sight" You rolled your eyes and sighed as you both returned to the table and leaned your head on his shoulder. At this the whispers grew louder and a few squeals could be heard.

"Oh for the love of-!"

"{Name} calm down" Toby said with a nervous laugh

"They are pissing me off!" Jeff chuckled

"They just don't believe you two are actually together, hell I still can't believe it and I saw the two of you making out!" You heard a few phrases like 'What?!' and 'No way!' from the other pastas which spread out quickly.

"That's it!"

"{Name} what-" You interrupted him by grabbing him by the collar of his shirt and crashing your lips on his. You heard gasps, squeals and someone doing a spit take at the sight. You broke the kiss and turned towards your spectators with a smirk.

"Alright anyone who didn't get that hint, yes! Toby and I are a couple now, so could all of you cut your yapping about us?!" The hall went silent, then laughter and finally it's normal idle chatter, well most of it. As for BEN, Jeff, Masky, Hoodie, Liu/Sully and Jane who were gasping for breath while holding their stomachs or banging the table with their fists.

"Oh! HA! I can't believe you actually-! HAHA! Did it!" BEN said trying to catch his breath between laughs

"{Name}! Why did you do that?!" Toby was blushing a deep shade of red all the way to his ears

"Oh come on! First, I find it hard to believe you weren't annoyed by that! Second don't act like you didn't like it and third, you better get used to it because I plan to do that every time I can, you're a damn good kisser" You finished with a wink that made him blush even more

"It wasn't that I didn't like it... you're really good too..." He murmured quietly but you heard him clearly. You smirked and leaned closer to his ear.

"Well if you want we could go somewhere else and continue where we left off~" You purred in his ear

"{Name}!" He looked at you with wide eyes which made you chuckle and sit up straight

"Relax I'm only half kidding" You winked and he sighed

"What am I going to do with you?" You laughed

"Love me a lot?" You smiled brightly and he smiled shyly

"I already do"

"Good because we're even then"