Forgive me? (Isaac Lahey x reader)

Forgive me? Chapter 2

Upon arriving home, you had called your parents and let them know what was going on. They were away for business. They were rarely ever home.

Grabbing a bag of chips from the kitchen, you made your way to your bedroom. Sitting down in front of your laptop, you opened it. Turning it on, you pulled out your copy of the Crucible from your bag. Opening it you started reading, typing as you went along things that seem important.

A few hours later, you woke to a knock on the door. Glancing down at the clock on your laptop, you noticed it was 3 o’clock already. Letting out a yawn, you made your way downstairs to the front door. Opening it, you were greeted with the sight of Isaac standing it there. You pushed the door shut and walked away. Isaac stuck his foot in the door, causing you to stop and turn around.

“Go away Isaac.” You told him, crossing your arms across your chest.

Isaac raised an eyebrow, pushing the door shut. “Not until you tell me what’s wrong.”

“Really Isaac, Don’t play stupid, you know what you did.” You rolled yours, giving him your best sarcastic tone, mocking his text from earlier.

“No I don’t.” He took a step toward you. You held out a hand toward him, motioning for him to stop.

“Really? You don’t know. Let’s start with the fact that Erica was all over you and you did nothing to stop her. If you want to be with her, don’t string me along. Go be with her.” You yelled at him, turning around so he wouldn’t see that you were about to start crying.

You felt a hand land on your shoulder and push you around. Isaac slid his other hand under your chin and tilted your head up. “What? I don’t want to be with her. I want to be with you. “Isaac used his thumbs to wipe away the tears leaking out of the corners of your eyes. “I love you y/n, not Erica. I’m sorry I didn’t stop her; I was just focused on doing the experiment. It won’t ever happen again.”

Isaac cupped your cheeks in his hand, pressing his lips against yours. The kiss started out slow and sweet, an apology. You knew that Isaac loved you and that he was probably absorbed in the experiment. When Isaac focused on something, he tended to forget anything and everyone around him.

You slid your arms around his neck, pulling his body closer to yours. Your eyes fluttered close as Isaac deepened the kiss, his tongue mapping the inside of your mouth. He pressed his pelvis against yours, pressing hard, causing you to let out a whimper in Isaac’s mouth at the feel of his erection.

You reluctantly pulled away from Isaac, wanting to continue the kiss but needing to take a breath. You stepped away from Isaac, letting your hands fall next to your sides. You took a couple of deep breaths before meeting Isaac’s gaze. He was staring down at you with a lustful gaze, that trademark smirk on his face. “Forgive me?” Isaac asked, stroking your cheek with his thumb. You nodded your head, giving him a smile. “Of course. You know I can never stay mad at you for long.”

Isaac grinned at you, reaching out his arm to grab yours and pulling you back into his embrace. He brushed the hair that had fallen in front of your face behind your ear. “Good because I really am sorry. I’ll talk to Erica and tell her she can’t do stuff like that.”

You nodded your head, giving Isaac a shy smile. You still weren’t use to Isaac being so sweet. Isaac wasn’t your first boyfriend but he definitely was the sweetest and most caring.
You pulled your arm from Isaac’s grip and took his hand in yours, linking your fingers together. You pulled on his hand indicating he should follow you as you made your way back to your room. You sat down on the bed, Isaac following suit.

“I heard you got suspended.” Isaac let go of your hand, to recline on your bed, propping himself up with the pillows on the bed.

You let out a laugh. “Yeah, for the rest of the day and tomorrow.” You laid back on the bed, your head laying on Isaac’s chest. His arm coming around to wrap around you. You placed your hand on Isaac’s chest, your fingers drawing shapes.

Isaac placed a kiss on the top of your head. “What do you want to do with the time you have off then?”

You drummed your hands on his chest, before sliding them down his body toward the button on his jeans. He grabbed your wrist, stopping you. He slide out from under you, and leaned over you, trapping your body beneath his. He gave you a grin, before pressing his lips against yours. This kiss wasn’t like earlier, slow and soft, this one was hard and passionate, his lips slightly bruising yours. You let your hands come up and press against the back of Isaac’s head, pulling him deeper into the kiss.

You moved your hands down to Isaac’s back, gripping the hem of his shirt, you pulled on it, silently asking him to take it off. He pulled away from the kiss to take his shirt off before he returned his lips to yours. He slid his hand under your shirt, skimming his fingers up your bare stomach, your skin instantly breaking out in goosebumps.

He then slid that hand behind your back to unclasp your bra. He broke off the kiss once again to pull off your shirt and bra. He then started placing kisses along your jaw down to your neck, alternating between placing kisses and sucking on the skin. As his lips moved down your jaw, he pinched your nipple, causing you to arch your back and press closer to him.

His mouth found the nipple he had pinched and took it into his mouth, sucking on it. You let out a gasp as his action caused a clenching in your core. You could feel him grinning against your breast as his hand slid down your stomach to the button on your jeans.

“Isaac..please.” He unbuttoned your jeans and slipped a hand into your underwear. Sucking harder on your nipple, his fingers found your clit and began to stroke it. His fingers dipping down to your opening, he pushed one finger and then another inside. Slowly, he moved them in and out. You let out a moan, your muscles clamping down on his fingers. His crooked his fingers in a “come hither” motion, hitting your g-spot. You felt the familiar pressure in your lower abdomen start building up. You pulled Isaac away from your breast to pull his lips down to yours. His finger skillfully worked at you as you kissed. You let out a moan of his name as your climax overtook you.

He removed his fingers, causing you to let out a small whimper. His hands reached for his own jeans, pulling them down along with his underwear. Isaac reached over to the nightstand next to your bed and pulled out a condom. Sheathing himself, he slid into you, causing you to gasp up at the intrusion.

You meet Isaac’s gaze as he gave you time to adjust to him, his blue eyes shining with arousal.. Isaac starting pumping his hips, starting out slow, he quickly picked up speed as your moans encouraged him to go faster.

“Don’t stop..please.” You moaned out. Isaac angled his hips to hit your sweet spot, his hand coming to rub your clit. You dug your nails into Isaac’s back as your climax started building, his thrusts and fingers finally pushing you over the edge. You let out a scream of Isaac’s name as white spots dance behind your vision. Isaac gave a couple more thrusts before he followed you over the edge.

He pulled himself out of you, pulled off the condom and threw it in the trash. He then laid down next to you on the bed. He wrapped his arms around you, pulling you into his side. Laying a kiss on the top of your head, he pulled the blanket up over the both of you.

“I love you Isaac.” You mumbled out tiredly as you closed your eyes.

“I love you too y/n.” He whispered, placing another kiss on your forehead.

You were just starting to doze off when the door bell rang. You jumped up out of bed and glanced out the window. A familiar blue jeep was sitting in your driveway, you had forgotten Stiles was coming over. “Shit, Stiles is here.”