~Love at first sight~|Noah Schnapp X reader|

Chapter 28|Would you cheat for me?

A/N before start I just want to shout out lauren02m . Her Noah Schnapp story is so amazing!! Im so in love with it! Go read it! Wanna get her to 1K reads!! Anyway, on with the story!

Y/N's pov
It's Christmas time. My group of friends decided to do a secret Santa. The limit was $30. I know just the present to buy. I got Noah, ironically. But he probably didn't get me because the probability of that is not big. Anyway, I'm going to get him a (animal of choice). It's slightly over $30 but it'll be fine. He loves (animal of choice plural) so he'll like it. I hope, lol.

Noah's pov
Idk what to get my secret santa. I don't really know her well and if I ask Y/N she'll know that person is my person.
I text Y/N
Me:Do u know what F/N wants?
Babe💞:A basketball. Those are pretty cheap if you're going to buy her one
Me:Thanks, babe. What are you getting your secret santa?
Babe💞: Im getting them a (animal of choice)
Me:Wow. You really are committed to this. Whoever gets it, I bet they'll love it
Babe💞:I know they will. I know that person very well
Me:Lol it almost sounds like you're saying it's me
Babe💞:But its not so... yeah
Me:Ok 🙄😂
Babe💞:Ok i gtg now. Shooping
Me:Lol shooping. Bye
I think I know who her person is 😏
Anyway, I call up Finn and ask him to come over. His mom said yes so he's on his way.

Time skip to when Finn gets to Noah's house...

"Hey, Finn" I say then I see his eyes are red. "Dude, what happened?"

"Nothing" he says and heads to my room.

"Please, just tell me. Im the chamber of secrets" I say and I hear him giggle.

"Look, I dont think I want to stay here."

"Why?" I ask.

"I really like her, Noah. And I can't bear to see her with you everyday. I always just want to run up to her and take her from you." He responds.

"Oh, Finn. I'm sorry" I say.

"I don't even know why I came here. I feel like that" he points to the picture of y/n and I "is making it worst."

I then scramble to take it down.

"Thanks man"He says. Then he hugs me.

"Im sorry, but I have to go" He says.

"You've only been here for like 10 minutes" I say.

"I HAVE to go" He snaps back. "Bye"

"Bye"

Y/N's pov
I hear a knock on my door. I wonder who it's for. My parents are gone so I guess its for me. Let's just see. (Im writing a song. Those are slightly modified lyrics from it)
I look out the peephole.
It's Finn.
I unlock the door and open it to him... crying.
"Hey, Finn. What happened?" I ask.

"I want to leave this town"He responds.

"What? Why?" I ask concerned.

"Because you and Noah are dating. And I dont like seeing you guys together." he replies.

"Im sorry. I dont wanna break up with Noah but I also want to be with you. What am I going to do?" I say.

"You could... date me at the same time" He says.

"I am not cheating on Noah" I say.

"What if he agrees to let you date both of us?" He asks.

"I don't know then" I say.

Then Finn comes close and puts his head against mine.

"Please. Ask him. I want to be with you. Really badly. And " He says then kisses me.

It was a long kiss. Long enough for Noah to see it as he walked to the front door.

"Y/N! H-how could you?" He exclaims. He's mad. I barely see him mad.

"It wasn't my f-" then Noah cuts me off.

"Im tired of catching you and Finn kiss. Are y'all going on dates, too? Tell me the whole truth and nothing but the truth." He says at an almost yell.

I tell him to come in and I lock the door. I'm home alone. And I'm scared. Not of being alone. Of them. What if they start a fight?

"Ok, I'm going to tell you everything, Noah" I pause. "I promise"

"Ok" he says. His eyebrows are furrowed.

"I have feelings for.... Finn." Noah makes a very angry expression. "But I have more for you. You're not the one who's trying to convince me to cheat"

"Finn." Noah pauses. "You stay away from her. I don't want interference. You're recking my relationship with y/n and im tired of it. You've always been jealous. Ever since we were at the hotel. You seemed happy with f/n but I guess you were just using her. Stay away. Stay away."

"You can't tell me that, little boy. I can be as close to her as I want. I can text and call her. I can walk to her house. You dont have the right to stop me. So stop trying to be her guardian because you're not doing a good job" Finn says and then leaves. "Bye, y/n. Love you"

"Bye" I say.

Noah then gets close to me and looks me right in the eye.

"Stay away from him" Then he comes and kisses me.

It wad a long kiss, too. But this one felt better.

"Hey, not be weird or anything but now you have Finn lip dna on your lips"I say.

He laughs and then says "I don't care. As long as I have yours."

Then we sit on the couch and watch Netflix.

"Can we watch Stranger Things?" I ask.

"Sure, why not?" He replies.

"Are we Netflix and chilling?" He asks with a grinn.

"Yeah, sure" then I roll my eyes and chuckle.

As the show begins, I get closet and closer to him. We begin cuddling.

           -()-()-()-()-()-()-()-()-()-()-
My parents wake Noah and I up. He asks if he can stay over and my parents say yes. We are going to fall asleep cuddling for the 3rd time now, but I don't mind. It's Noah.

A/N I hope you guys liked it!! Thank you so much for 11k reads!!! I love y'all so much. I still need request!! Do you like the long chapters? This ones 1035 words! Im going to try to keep them this length unless it's a huge cliffhanger. Anyway, if I dont update alot it means I have a life. Jk, im just really busy. Im in dance, basketball, band and school and all the events for these are right on top of each other. So I hope you understand. Thank you for 13k reads!! More to come!! Bye,bye, bbies!! 💞