Creepypasta Lemons

Ticci Toby x Reader

(y/n)'s pov:
It had only been a month since you joined the creepypasta household, but you already felt right at home with your new murderer family. You loved your new home, but you also loved one more thing, and that was Toby. You thought his little tics and stutters were adorable. You just didn't know how to tell him.

It was morning and you were sitting down in the kitchen. Everyone was gone killing except you and Toby. You look up to see Toby look over to you groggily, clearly just waking up. He smiles and walks over to you. "H-hey (y/n) want some w-w-waffles?" he had a big smile on his face. "Sure! You know I'd never turn down food." He chuckled and started walking away. "Ok I'll be r-right b-back." 'Damn his laugh is hot'. You had the dumbest smile on your face just from thinking about him.

Toby's pov:

I went into the kitchen after talking to (y/n). I was finally going to tell her how I feel about her, and what better way than with waffles! I made some heart shaped waffles and put whipped cream and fruit on top. It looked so good that I was tempted to eat it myself! I brought it over to (y/n) and the smile on her face was priceless. Here goes nothing...

"(y/n)... I've been m-meaning to t-tell you for a l-long time now... I really l-l-like you!" I was blushing so hard and dying of anxiety. What if she rejects me. I was suddenly brought out of my thoughts by (y/n) kissing me. I melted into the kiss and we later separated for air. "I like you too Toby." I couldn't believe what I was hearing.

(y/n)'s pov:

Toby immediately brought you into another kiss. It was full of lust and want. Without breaking the kiss he picked you up and carried you up to his room, setting you down on the bed. He left butterfly kisses down your neck until he found your sweet spot, a quiet moan escaping your lips. He grinned then began abusing that spot, sucking and biting it until it was a large dark spot.

Toby's pov:
Her moans were the sexiest things I'd ever heard. I took off (y/n)'s shirt and bra, and her face turned ten shades of red. She covered her self. I kissed her and she became visually less tense. I looked into her (e/c) eyes. "It's o-okay I'll be g-gentle." She smiled and uncovered herself.

I brought my kisses lower down to her breasts, as I began sucking on one while playing with the other. (y/n)'s breathing quickened as light airy moans could be heard. Smirking ear to ear, I gave the other one the same treatment until they were both coated in saliva. My lips went lower and lower until I was at the hem of her pants. I rubbed up and down her thighs and looked up at her now deep red face, hinting I wanted to take it further. She nodded and I slowly and teasingly took off her pants, leaving her only in soaked panties.
She looked up at me and pouted. "How is it fair that I'm almost completely naked and you're still fully dressed?" A mischievous grin spread across my face. "Well w-why don't you h-help me out with t-t-that?"

(y/n)'s pov:
I got the hint and flipped us so I was now straddling Toby's hips, and pulled his hoodie off along with his shirt, admiring his now visible toned chest. I brought us into a heated kiss as I began to undo his belt. He shifted so I could completely pull them off, leaving him in his boxers.
My eyes widened a little as I saw how big he was. "See something you L-like?" I looked up at him with needy eyes. He seemed to have gotten the message because he flipped us back over so that he was on top, and took off his boxers before taking off my now drenched panties and positioned himself at my dripping entrance.

Toby's pov:
I looked into (y/n)'s beautiful (e/c) eyes. "A-are you ready?" She nodded and I slowly and carefully entered her and brought her into a kiss to distract her from the pain. I used all of my strength to stop myself from pounding into her, as I waited for her to signal that I could move. After a minute she moved her hips, giving me permission to continue.
I began to slowly thrust into her, feeling her walls hug my aching member tight. "Toby please go faster" she said in between moans. I obeyed, plunging myself deeper and quicker into her warm and soaking wet core. We were both in complete bliss, panting and moaning was all that could be heard. I began going even faster as moans were flying out of her mouth, begging for me to go faster. My thrusts became sloppy as I began getting closer to my release. I could feel her tightening, meaning she wasn't to far away either. "Toby, I'm gonna c-cum!" "Me t-too!" With one final thrust I sent both of us over the edge, my cum going deep into her, and hers all over my throbbing member. I pulled out, and laid down next to (y/n), who was trying to catch her breath. Snuggling up to me, I heard a faint "I love you." I kissed her head. "I love you too." We just laid there, snuggling and accepting each others love, because we finally had each other after a long lack of courage.