One Time [Montgomery De La Cruz x OC]

When the unknown becomes the known.

NEW CHARACTERS!

                                                         Bella Hadid as Marissa Whitmore

                                                               Matthew Morrison as Alex Whitmore

                                                             Jennifer Aniston as Jane Whitmore

A/N: I decided to give a new thing a try in this chapter... it will go back and forth between Monty's POV and Marci's POV!

Monty's POV

I walked into Monet's before school to grab some coffee. I let the girls sleep in since it's the last week of school and I did the babies morning routine myself and then dropped them off at daycare. Getting up early after being up literally all night having sex with Marci over and over and over again was kicking my ass though. I didn't know what had gotten into her but it's like she needed any form of reassurance from me constantly that I still loved her and wanted to be with her. She told me late last night in between sex that she was scared that I was gonna leave her for someone who didn't so easily manipulate my emotions, so I figured that's where it was coming from. She kept on talking about my feelings for Lyla too and I knew that her hormones were a big contributing factor in her new "I'm scared I'm gonna lose you" attitude. Even though I definitely wasn't used to a clingy and sex crazed Marci, I kind of liked all of the new found affection but at the same time, it was beginning to become too much. I shouldn't have to dedicate every second of my life to her or have to listen to her cry about how I wanted Lyla instead of her and that's why I was gone for five minutes instead of two. I was worn out though either way, so coffee was definitely needed. I walked up to the front and placed my order. As soon as I told the barista my name, I heard a group of girls behind me giggling excitedly. I turned around and saw a group of probably 15 or 16 year old girls sitting at the table behind me. They all blushed as soon as I looked at them and I couldn't help but to smirk and look them all over. I loved Marci and was loyal to her but for some reason, I really felt like I needed to pay attention to these girls. I stopped my eyes on one and I couldn't help but to feel like she looked strangely familiar. She didn't look exactly like someone but some of her features were the same. I looked at her more closely and I had to stop my jaw from dropping whenever I realized who she reminded me of. She looked like Marci. Their skin tone was the same, their smiles weren't the same but were so similar you'd have to really pay attention to notice the difference, this girls hair was just as thick and curly as Marci's, hers was just dark where Marci's is blonde. They had almost exactly the same body type except Marci is crazy short and has child sized hands and feet and this girl was tall and was proportionally the size of a normal teenage girl. I moved a little closer and listened to her talk. Her voice was so much like my fucking fiancés that I had to take a step back. This girls voice was a little higher pitched than Marci's but they were so much alike it was crazy. I stared too long and her friends all thought I was checking her out so they got her to look at me and whenever she did, my fucking heart stopped right there. Those damn eyes. Holy fucking shit her eyes were identical to Marci's. Ocean eyes. This girl had ocean eyes too. I had never seen a pair of eyes like Marci's before but this girl looked like she had plucked Marci's eyes straight out of her head and put them in her own. I just kept staring at her and she got up and approached me. "Montgomery De La Cruz, right?" She smiled and I just nodded my head. Still baffled. "I'm Marissa Whitmore." "Wait, what the fuck did you just say your last name is?" I said so fast it startled her and her friends who were listening. "Whitmore?" She chuckled confused. "Holy fuck." I whispered to myself. This couldn't just be a crazy coincidence. They looked too much alike and they have the same last name. Marci's mom gave her her dads last name even though he was out of the picture. We all knew that her mom didn't have any more kids after Marci but did her dad? What if my tiny girls long lost little sister was standing right in front of my face right now? "How... how old are you?" I asked her. "Just turned sixteen." She smirked and then ran her hand up my arm. Shit, she wanted me. I didn't push her away though because I wanted more answers. "What grade are you in?" "Tenth, but only for another week." She smirked again and moved her hand to my hair and started playing with it. "I love your hair." She flirted. She was definitely more flirtatious than Marci, that's for sure. Marci never led me to believe that she wanted to fuck me and definitely didn't show signs that she was in love with me until after Savannah's conception. This girl was completely different. If I wanted to, I could've probably taken her in the back and fucked her right now. My girl was classier than that though and I loved that about her. "You're so tall and big." She flirted again. "Yeah, so I've been told." I mumbled, separating my sentence. "Have you always lived here? I've never seen you around." I finished. "Not my whole life but most of it. I moved her whenever I was five because my dad said he grew up here and that he had some loose ends he never got to finish tying up here. So, we moved back." She said with a shrug of her shoulder, inching closer to me. "Do you have any siblings?" "No, I'm an only child. Well... I apparently have an older sister somewhere but my dad never told me her name because he didn't want us to interfere in her life after he fucked up and left her with her apparently bitch of a mom." She answered. Holy shit. Everything is just adding up. Bitch of a mom is right though. Marci's mom has never really given a damn about her and left her alone from a very young age. Before I could say anything else, she pushed her body up against mine and continued playing with my hair. We were pushed flush together, right there in the middle of Monet's. As soon as I went to push her off of me, I heard a gasp. "What the fuck, Montgomery?" Jessica yelled. Damn it. Justin was standing next to her looking disappointed. Since it was the last two weeks of school whenever Grace was born, they were only able to take off last week and had to come back to school today to finish the last week of school. They had put Grace in the same daycare as Savannah and Dallas. "Jess, I swear..." I said panicking. "I don't care to hear your bullshit excuses... look at all of those hickeys on your neck!" Jessica interrupted me. She was still hormonal from the baby being born so she wasn't rationally thinking and realizing that the hickeys were from her best friend. "You think I got fucking hickeys in the middle of Monet's? They're from Marci!" I argued back. "Marci? Who's Marci?" Marissa spoke up. "Oh my God, Monty. The whore doesn't even know about Mar?" Jessica yelled again and Justin was trying to calm her down. "I was so proud of you for how much you'd changed but clearly you're still a cheating ass man whore!" Jessica yelled again before storming out of Monet's. "Come on, man. What the fuck?" Justin said while shaking his head before following after Jessica. Neither one of them even gave me the chance to explain but I understood how bad it looked. "So... who is Marci?" Marissa asked after a minute. She had backed away some now and I was thankful for that. "My fiancé, the mother of my children, and I think... your sister."