the cover wars

WINNERS

congratulations to everyone for creating such amazing graphics, I was seriously blown away, and it made judging so much harder. Since there are so many of you this early on in the competition, I will not be commenting on everyone's work, instead justifying my choice by showing my steps in judging, and if you'd like, you can pm me for a full break down of why I gave you the score I did.

First, I individually scored each piece, isolated from one another, to get a rough idea of the standings. As you can see from this, the quality of most pieces was insanely high.

thelollipopkid
10/10
8/10 - set image
18/20

viciouscupcake- -
10/10
8/10 - set image
18/20

lavencraw
10/10
8/10 - set image
18/20

WORLDCRY
7/10
10/10 - set image
17/20

strayinspace
9/10
8/10 - set image
17/20

mirabilia-
8/10
9/10 - set image
17/20

curiousIy
8/10
9/10 - set image
17/20

mieczy-slaw
8/10
8/10 - set image
16/20

kinksheets
9/10
7/10 - set image
16/20

introverted_mess
7/10 - set image
9/10
16/20

scrappily
8/10
8/10 - set image
16/20

beauior
7/10
8/10 - set image
15/20

stellardurst
7/10
8/10 - set image
15/20

MiaOswald
8/10
6/10 - set image
14/20

Queen__2005
7/10
6/10 - set image
13/20

MoonyChris
6/10 - set image
5/10
11/20

MaybeHarleen
5/10
5/10 - set image
10/20

EARTHSETTES
5/10 - set image
5/10
10/20

Then, in order to get these results and differentiate from pieces, I compared them to each other, to see which pieces struck me as the most memorable and skilful.

To show the winners, I picked their best graphic out of the two to comment on, and vice versa for the eliminated. So here are the results !

In third: viciouscupcake-