Credit to this idea from cinnamonroll_girl (go check out her books)
Wyatt:
*he got you this for your birthday*
Jaeden:
*he got you this when he saw it at the store*
Jack:
*he won it for you at the fair*
Chosen:
*got it for you, for your birthday*
Jeremy:
*bought it for you for valentines day*
Nic:
*you pointed it out and he bought it for you*
Finn:
*got it for you for your birthday*
Noah:
*Got it for you for your birthday*
Gaten:
*he won it for you at an arcade*
Caleb:
*got it for you for christmas*
Charlie:
*randomly got it for you*
Joe:
*you were sad*