Killing for You (Creepypasta Fan Fiction)

Chapter Five: Killing

Kira's POV

"YOU'RE WHAT!?" Caitlyn yelled out

We had just been told the news that the people whom we were face to face with at this moment were all insane killers. I mean, it could be worse. They could all be rapists. *Hint hint to Sexual Offenderman*

I, other than Caitlyn, found it pretty fascinating. I know I know, call me crazy. I've always had a love for things that were gruesome and bloody. I guess I'm insane as well.

"Don't scream, you'll wake the children." Slenderman added calmly. 

"Well I'm sorry but it's kind of shocking to find this out." Said Caitlyn

"Really?" Toby started, "I thought you would have guessed it just by looking at us. I mean, you slept with Jeff, didn't you notice all the blood stains on the hoodie?"

I burst out laughing and Caitlyn turned a furious shade of red. Jeff just stood with his shoulder slumped onto me and smirked. I doubt that they actually did anything, but by what Toby and I saw that night I would have guessed they got a little more into it.

"I don't really see a problem with it. As long as they don't kill us, then we're good." I said while looking at Caitlyn.

"So... You don't have a problem with any of this?" Toby asked

"Well the way I see it, if it makes you happy then go right the fuck ahead."

"Man... You're perfect" He muttered 

"What was that?"

"Nothing."

We all continued to talk about the subject of killing and how each one of them did it. I found BEN's the best way out of them all, through a video game. 

"Just a thought, since everybody here is a killer, does that mean that we have to kill, too?" I asked Slenderman. He shifted in his seat slightly and gave me a half relieved look.

"I was going to say that, thank you. But yes, it does mean that you both will have to learn the skills and find your own ways to murder." 

I was smiling from ear to ear, same with Toby and Jeff. Caitlyn on the other hand didn't look so pleased.  I could tell she didn't want to do this one bit.

"Do we, err.. Have to do it?" She asked

"Well child," Slenderman started, "It's either kill for yourself, or we kill you." Caitlyn got a look of dread in her eyes. 

MAGIC TIME SKIP OoOo

It was getting late when LJ came downstairs with BEN and I. We were just talking while BEN played his video games when it got strangely quiet. I looked at LJ and he looked back at me and I heard him say stuff without his lips moving. What the fuck. 

Oh god I hope she'll be okay tonight. Maybe I should go with them...

"Who are you talking about?" I asked him. His eyes went wide. 

"... How did you know..." I just shrugged and gave him a 'beats me' look. A couple minutes later Masky came running down the stairs while Jeff tailed right behind him, and Hoodie behind Jeff. 

"MASKY! GET YOUR STUPID ASS OVER HERE" Jeff screamed. I looked at him, then to Masky, then to Hoodie, then back to Jeff again. Hoodie leaned towards me and whispered

"Hehe um... We were in Jeff's room and long story short his room is no longer white and red..." I laughed way too hard. 

"OH my god I need to see this." I got up leaving Masky defenceless to Jeff and Hoodie giving me a 'really' look. I turned down the corridor to meet Sally who grabbed my wrist and pulled me to Jeff's room where Caitlyn was sitting on the floor covered in pink dust. 

"Man.. I love what you've done with the place." I laughed with tears in my eyes as Caitlyn and Sally joined in. 

We stopped laughing finally to see that Sally and I were now covered in pink dust, too. I started thinking about what had happened with LJ earlier. 

"Hey Caitlyn, have you noticed anything strange happening to you since we've been here?" 

"Not really, other than the fact that I seem to be attracted to a killer." She just can't let that go.

"Weird. I was downstairs with BEN and LJ and I could heard LJ talking without him opening his mouth. Kinda like a read his mind." Sally looked towards me with a smile

"Kira! You're getting it! You're finding your powers. In other words, you're becoming a creepypasta like the rest of us!" Oh. My. Fuck.

Caitlyn looked over to me grinning. She looked petrified. 

"Oh calm down Caitlyn, yes I'm going to kill people. I won't kill you." I laughed as I said the last part. She, however, did not take it very happily. I hope she knows that if I'm turning into one, she'll be one in no time as well. She just sighed and gave the 'carry on' hand motion. I jumped up and ran for the door. The door opened and I caught a small glimps of Toby before we collided together in the pink dust. I laughed and saw him puffing it out from his mouth guard. 

"What the hecky happened in here..." He asked. Sally, Caitlyn, and I just shrugged our shoulders and laughed. 

I told Toby about what happened and he was very happy. And when I say very happy, I mean very freaking happy. He literally picked me up while we were hugging and he was jumping on the bed. I start my training soon. I just hope Caitlyn doesn't fall behind.