Reader X Ticci Tobi X Reader

Chapter 15...Meeting other Pastas

1st Reader Pov
     I dreamed about all the things that could go wrong...what if Toby likes [2nd Readers Name] more than me...my dreams started to turn to nightmares...

Nightmare...
     "Hahaha," [2nd Readers Name] laughed, "let's just leave her here." Toby nodded his head happily and they left me behind in the tree. They ran away together but stopped to look back at me. When they did they looked disgusted and looked back at each other and kissed. It was small but when they broke apart they looked into each others eyes. They started to have a passionate make out session.
     There was a flash and suddenly they were at the mansion and Toby was introducing her to everyone. They all liked having her around and Slenderman let her stay with Toby. She laughed and kissed Toby again. Toby lead her up to his room and they ate waffles together. They were so happy and lost in each others eyes. Slowly they got closer and closer until they had another passionate make out session. They moved across the room and started giggling.
     There was another flash and [2nd Readers Name] was pregnant. She looked so happy, they both did. The other Pastas would go to check up on her and give her things for the baby. Suddenly Toby left the room, when he came back he had a waffle plushy. It looked exactly like the one I had at home. She gladly accepted it and put it in the baby crib. Toby walked up to her and gently kissed her before kissing her stomach and saying, "I'm g-gonna be a d-dad."
     There was yet again another flash and they were in Dr. Smiles hospital. Everyone was congratulating them on there baby. People were all around [2nd Readers Name] and Toby so I couldn't see the baby. Jane walked up and said, "I wonder if the kid will stutter like Toby." Toby playfully glared at her and she laughed. He looked at Slenderman and said, "it c-can grow to b-be a Creepypasta like a-all of u-us." Slenderman seemed to smile and said, "we will all make sure the child is in perfect health and protect it." Toby and Slenderman hugged. "Th-thanks Slenderman," said Toby happily. Jeff came up and whispered, "I'm gonna teach it about knives." Everyone laughed and BEN said, "typical Jeff and his love of knives." Him and Jeff got into a playful fight with each other before heading to sit in the mansions living room. Slowly everyone left the room. All that was left was Toby, [2nd Readers Name], and the baby. Once the baby came to view I saw it was a boy. His eyes were E/C like [2nd Readers Name]'s and he had brown hair like Toby.
     Images of them all growing up together happily flashed in my mind.
End of Nightmare...

I suddenly woke up and looked around to make sure I wasn't alone. Toby and [2nd Readers Name] were still asleep so I relaxed a bit and whispered, "it was just a nightmare."

2nd Reader Pov
     I dreamed about me, Toby, and [1st Readers Name] in a place made of all waffles. It was the best place ever.

Dream...
     "Hurry up [2nd Readers Name]," yelled Toby. He was running all over the place. Everything was made of waffles and Toby was having the time of his life. We followed him happily and watched as he jumped down a slide of syrup. Somehow it wasn't sticky but then again it's a dream so why would it be. As I followed Toby he started to slow down. We came to a stop in front of a giant waffle castle. Of course Toby ran into the caste excitedly so I chased after him. "Wait up," I yelled. Suddenly I couldn't see [1st Readers Name] anymore. "That's strange," I whispered. I walked into a room and saw Toby sitting at a table eating waffles. "So many waffles...yay," I squealed. I ran to sit by Toby and immediately stabbed a waffle with my fork. I heard a little scream and jumped out of my seat.
     When I looked at my plate I saw that the waffle was alive. "How cute," I whispered. Suddenly the waffle snapped my fork in half and threw it at me. I dodged it and started getting a bit scared. I looked around but Toby was gone. Where could he have gone...I thought. Suddenly the waffles started approaching me angrily. They jumped at me so I reached for my knife. It wasn't there...no no no. Hundreds of waffles started jumping on me. I couldn't stand the weight and fell flat on my face. They just kept coming and coming. I was being buried alive by waffles...no no no no no this can't be happening. Looking up I saw Toby in the doorway. I reached out to him but soon enough my vision was filled with more and more waffles as they started to burry me beneath them.
     They started biting me and it really hurt. I tried to scream from the pain and scream for help but I couldn't make a sound. When I tried to move to escape them I realized I couldn't move either. I was going to die because of waffles.
End of Dream...

I woke up and looked around to make sure there were no killer waffles. I realized [1st Readers Name] was also awake. It must have been a dream...I thought to myself. We both stretched and waited for Toby to wake up. It only took a few minutes before he started opening his eyes. "Good morning Toby," we said in unison.

Ticci Toby Pov
     When I woke up I noticed that [1st Readers Name] and [2nd Readers Name] were already awake. "Good morning Toby," they said in unison. I lifted my goggles and rubbed the sleep away from my eyes. [2nd Readers Name] stood up and helped [1st Readers Name] stand up before they both helped me up. I smiled and jumped down from the tree. You both followed behind me and we started walking through the woods again.
     Suddenly I heard the familiar voice of the one the only Jeff the Killer. "Hey Toby who are these two," he said as he pointed his knife at you two. I sighed and said, "i-it's none of y-your b-business Jeff." He looked at me angrily and said, "well does Slendy know about them?" I looked at him sternly and said, "I-I'll tell h-him later." Jeff looked at you both with this strange look...then again he always looks strange...before he finally said, "the names Jeff sweethearts so don't forget it." [1st Readers Name] scoffed and said, "we already know who you are Jeffrey." We all laughed while Jeff looked like he was about to blow. "Don't EVER call me Jeffrey...my name is Jeff the Killer got that," he yelled at you. He took out his knife again and pointed it at you threateningly. [1st Readers Name] and [2nd Readers Name] both pulled out their knives and said, "we're so scared." They said it in a sarcastic tone and Jeff looked shocked.
     "Jeff!," yelled another familiar voice. I looked to my right to see an angry BEN. "You Broke My Favorite GameBoy!," he yelled. "H-Hey BEN," I said casually. BEN started fighting Jeff while yelling many different names at each other. "Zelda!," yelled Jeff. "Stupid Joker!," yelled BEN. Suddenly [2nd Readers Name] yelled, "ladies ladies your both beautiful now can you shut up for five minutes!" I looked at her a bit shocked. No human has ever dared to yell at a Creepypasta before...I thought. Suddenly they both stopped fighting and BEN floated over to you two. "Why hello the names BEN DROWNED," he said while trying to act cool, "if you two ever need anything I'm always available." You two broke out laughing and said in unison, "we know who you are and we're good with Toby but thanks."
     BEN looked at me angrily and asked, "why do they like you so much." I shrugged my shoulders and hugged you both. Upon doing so you both giggled and blushed. It was really cute. I looked at BEN and he looked a bit annoyed before saying, "I almost forgot...Slenderman asked us to go find you cause he wants to see you." This is the perfect chance for me to tell him about [1st Readers Name] and [2nd Readers Name]...lets just hope that he won't be mad...we all started walking back to the mansion.
     BEN kept on making stupid pickup lines that you would always have a rejection comeback to use. After awhile he got angry and yelled, "I give up!!!" Everyone laughed except for BEN. "Finally," whispered [1st Readers Name]. Soon the mansion came to view and we headed to Slenderman's office. I opened the door and said, "you w-wanted to s-see me?"