Reader X Ticci Tobi X Reader

Chapter 19...First Kiss

Ticci Toby Pov
     I started to think...make my move...but when would I do that...would they regent me and laugh about it...where would I make my move...does make my move mean that I kiss them...or...what did they mean by that...maybe I could make my move on them both by the lake...yeah that's a good idea...the lake is really nice and they would love it...I hope they do...I was taken away from my thoughts when [1st Readers Name] tapped me on the shoulder. "Y-yeah," I asked her.
     "You looked deep in thought," she paused, "what are you thinking about?" I stared at her and realized that I had been standing still for awhile now. "N-nothing," I stuttered, "why d-do you think I-I was thinking about s-something." I could hear the nervousness in my voice but I hoped that she hadn't. "Okay," she said happily...thank goodness she didn't question me...I decided to take a walk to the lake to make sure it was perfect.
     As I walked I noticed that [1st Readers Name] and [2nd Readers Name] were following me. Oh no...they're following me...what do I do now...I guess I could make my move since they're following me there...it does make things easier...I thought as I kept walking. I turned my head to the side to check that nobody was following us. When I was sure nobody was there I let my guard down a bit. We were almost at the lake and I wanted to stop worrying about others.

2nd Reader Pov
     Me and [1st Readers Name] decided to follow To y outside. He seemed to be going somewhere with confidence and nervousness at the same time...I wonder what he's nervous about...we kept following him. Suddenly he looked around the woods to check our surroundings. After awhile of looking he relaxed a bit and continued to walk. When he finally stopped walking we were standing in front of a gorgeous lake. It was so beautiful and almost clear...now I wanna go swimming...is that why he came here...to go swimming...I guess I'll just wait and see...
     Toby sat down on a rock beside the lake and motioned for us to sit by him. We sat there for a moment in silence. It wasn't an awkward silence or anything, it was actually a comforting silence. Toby suddenly spoke up, "[1st Readers Name]...[2nd Readers Name]...I-I really l-like you guys." I looked at him a bit shocked and he turned to both of us. "P-please take o-off your masks," he said. He seemed really nervous and was slightly blushing.
     We both took off our masks slowly and looked at Toby. "What is it T..." before I could finish my sentence Toby kissed me...he just kissed me...and on the lips too...omg this is my first kiss...he pulled away and kissed [1st Readers Name] as well. Once he was done he looked at us both. All of us were blushing like crazy...of course you all are...that was probably all of our first kiss..."I think I love you guys," he confessed. "We love you too," I whispered to him. [1st Readers Name] nodded her head in agreement and Toby smiled. We all hugged and me and [1st Readers Name] kissed Toby on his cheeks.
     Suddenly clapping could be heard from behind us. I turned around and saw all of the Creepypastas...I even saw Slenderman and his three brothers! "Good job Toby," said Offenderman as he looked at me and [1st Readers Name]'s faces, "you actually got two nice looking girls at the same time." I blushed and looked away. "Wahoo," screamed the Creepypastas, "go Toby!" I blushed even more and looked at Toby. "If they get married I am definitely making the outfits!," screeched Trenderman. "Alright children let's get back to the mansion," said Slenderman, "and congratulations Toby." He gave Toby a thumbs up before ushering everyone to go back to the mansion for lunch.
     We sat there for a moment before heading back to the mansion together. Once we arrived we sat together at the table and were given our lunches. I had a Philly Cheese Steak sandwich and [1st Readers Name] had a salad, Toby of course had waffles. I smiled and ate my sandwich in peace. Jane stood up with her glass in one hand and looked at Toby, "I give you luck with these two...but know this Toby...they cry and your dead." She sat down and everyone laughed. Toby gulped and sank in his chair a bit. I could tell he was scared so I put my hand on his. He looked at me and smiled. "Th-thanks," he whispered. "You're welcome," I whispered back.  We all sat there eating peacefully while others had random conversations like, "I wonder who he loves more?" I ignored it but Toby didn't he stared them down angrily.
     Toby stood up and said, "I l-love them both e-equally!"

1st Reader Pov
     Suddenly Toby stood up and said, "I l-love them both e-equally!" I looked at him a bit shocked until I noticed him glaring at Clockwork and BEN. They probably questioned who he likes...me or [2nd Readers Name]...they act like its a big contest where we will have to fight to be loved more than the other by Toby...boy are they wrong...he does love us equally and we are friends so we are okay with being equalized...I glared at BEN and he hid behind Clockwork. "She said it not me!," he yelled as he pointed at Clockwork. "I admit I said it," she said while raising her hands into the air in a sign of surrender. I sighed and looked at the angry Toby, "it's okay we know that you love us equally and that's all that matters." He sighed and sat down to finish his waffles. He was so cute when he got angry but I didn't want him angry.
     "Let's go take a nap," suggested [2nd Readers Name]. Toby and I nodded in agreement and headed to his room to cuddle and take a nap. Once at his room we all cuddled up on the bed and fell asleep to the sound of each other's breathing.