Capricorn~ eyeless jack
Aquarius~ laughing jack
Pisces~ Jason the toymaker
Aries~ Geoff the killer
Taurus~ ticci toby
Gemini~ bean drowned
Cancer~ puppeteer
Leo~ the rake
Virgo~ offenderman (I'm so so sorry)
Libra~ slenderman
Scorpio~ masky
Sagittarius~ hoodie