Aries - Kagekao: "If I prank you then pay you after, will you still kill me?"Taurus - BEN Drowned: "....I'm not saying I am, but would you still game with me if I said I was a pervert?"
Gemini - Jane The Killer: "Would you help me in hunting down Jeff, if I asked?"
Cancer - Jeff The Killer: ".....Wanna have a staring contest?"
Leo - Ticci-Toby: "DO YA LIKE WAFFLES, YES I LIKE WAFFLES DO YOU LIKE PANCAKES YES I LIKE PAN—No, but seriously, do you like waffles?"
Virgo - Laughing Jack: "Do you happen to fancy insane, creepy-looking clowns? HEHEHEHEHEE—" *randomly bursts out laughing*
Libra - Bloody Painter: "Would you freak out if I accidentally spilled a bucket of blood over your head? Just asking."
Scorpio - Puppeteer: "Do you like it when I sing, as I use my golden string?"
Sagittarius - Eyeless Jack: "Want to try a kidney? I'm pretty tired of being the only one here that gets looked at strange because of my choice in food....well not really my choice, it's necessity."
Capricorn - Smile Dog: "Pet me? Pet me?? PET ME?? PETMEPETMEPETMEPETMEPETME—"
Aquarius - Slenderman: "Would you be willing to be one of my proxies?"
Pisces: Also Slenderman: "And do you really have to sleep all day?"