One Direction Preferences

They're Dating Your Sister But Realize They Love You

*IMPORTANT A/N AT THE END!*

(Y/S/N)=Your Sister's Name

-----

Harry:
It was a slow Tuesday summer evening as you walked to the kitchen, passing the living room and seeing your sister and Harry-her gorgeous boyfriend-watching a movie. "Hi Harry, how are you?" You smiled. "Hey (Y/N). Good, you?" Although his voice was shaky, he tried to compose it. Weird. "Good." You walked to the fridge, grabbing a water bottle and siting at the table. You took out your phone, going to text your friend and see if a sleepover is in the picture tonight. Just as you hit send, Harry walks in alone. "Um, (Y/N)..." He cleared his throat, sitting across from you. "I need to tell you something." You nod, letting him continue. "I... well I'd say I love you, but that's strong. I do, however, have feelings for you and I know I'm dating your sister, but ever since she introduced me to you, I couldn't stop thinking of you. I've just been holding it in for too God damn long..." Silence filled the room for a few seconds before you whispered it apart. "Have you told her?" His head lowered, fingers lacing. This could only mean one thing. "Not yet." He said.

Liam:
"(Y/N)!" You heard your sister call for you from the den. Poking your head through the door frame, you raised your eyebrows, "yeah?" You saw her and Liam cuddled together across the couch. "Want to play truth or dare with us?" You nodded, smiling and sitting on the chair next to them. "You go first, (Y/S/N)." You said. "Okay, (Y/N), truth or dare?"
"Dare."
"Um... put an ice cube in your mouth and let it sit there until it melts, not taking it out." You sighed at your sister and went to get an ice cube. About two minutes of pure torture later, the ice cube was gone and you were pretty sure you have frost bite now. "Liam, truth or dare?" You said, trying to warm your tongue by blowing out. "Truth." He smiled. "Say the first word that pops into your head when I say three words." He nodded as you took a second to think.
"Butterfly."
"Flower."
"Stadium."
"Fans."
"Love."
"(Y/N)."

Zayn:
Your sister made you watch a live stream of a One Direction concert she wasn't able to attend due to a sickness. Ever since Zayn said he wrote a song for her, she's been bugging the whole house about it. 'Do you have a song about you? I do!' She'd say. 'My boyfriend is the sweetest! He wrote a song for me!' Honestly, it got super annoying after a while. You mean, it was an adorable thing in general, just not all her talk about it. "(Y/N)," she squealed through slight coughs, pointing at the screen, "he's on, he's talking!" You chuckled, nodding slightly. "This song I wrote for my love, my muse, my sunshine. I hope you like it babe! I love you (Y/N)." As soon as he said your name, you gasped and looked at your sister. Tears were already in her eyes before the TV went black and the noise lowered to a soft murmur of her small cries.

Niall:
"You know," you said as Niall left small kisses down your neck, "we really shouldn't be doing this." You felt Niall shrug, pulling your body closer to his. You sighed, trying to push him away with no luck. "I'm your girlfriend's sister for God's sake! This is so so wrong..." Niall smiled, moving along your jawline now. "But it feels so so right." He whispered in your ear, sending shivers down your spine. It took a few seconds of arguing in your heads before you stopped him, looking into his eyes. "We can't. I can't. You're dating my sister, Niall." His head hung low, eyes shamed. Both your minds were into it, but your hearts know it is too bad. "But," Niall spoke, looking into your eyes, "I love you (Y/N)."

Louis:
Your sister and Louis had an extra ticket to a soccer game, inviting you to go along. You obviously said yes because it's totally a one-in-a-lifetime opportunity! "I'm going to go to the bathroom. Anyone else need to go?" Your sister asked, getting up. Both you and Louis shook your heads, engrossed in the last minute of the first half. Your sister walked away, leaving you alone next to Louis. You took a look over at him, seeing his face scrunch in disappointment as the whistle blew to signal half time. "They missed," he said, shaking his head and awakening you from your trance. "Damn... hey look, kiss cam!" You pointed to the big screen showing a happy couple. You smiled as you saw many different people come up until you saw Louis and you. Your smile faded and you went pale. Before you knew what was happening, Louis grabbed you and kissed you-long and hard-on the lips. "I love you." He quickly said, kissing you once more and the screen catching it all. You could only hope your sister didn't hear any of it although knowing eventually she'd see the video.

-----

Hello! Okay, so these are some requested preferences from before. I'm not writing as much on here though because of my fanfic (Beginning of the End (AU0-Michael Clifford, if you guys want to check it out).

Please DO NOT reqeust anymore, I'm not taking requests currently because of the fanfic. I will update on my own but just not requested or regularly. Thank you!<3

Also, maybe you wanna follow my tumblr? I do ships, blurbs, au memes, preferences with gif+pictures, and personal imagines! asiancxlum.tumblr.com
-Alyssa XOXO