One thing Natalie loves to get for Christmas is a new watch to replace her first one. She just slaps whoever gets that for them. (Which is usually Jeff or Ben.)
Creepypasta Headcanons
Table of contents-
Disclaimer
-
#1 Homicidal Liu
-
#2 Ticci Toby
-
#3 Toby, Jeff, LJ
-
#4 BEN Drowned
-
#5 Eyeless Jack
-
Piper's Profile (Not Really Important)
-
#6 Laughing Jack
-
#7 BEN Drowned
-
#8 Clockwork
-
#9 Jeff the Killer
-
#10 BEN Drowned
-
#11 Jane the Killer
-
#12 Eyeless Jack
-
#13 Bloody Painter
-
#14 Laughing Jack
-
#15 Sally
-
#16 Puppeteer
-
#17 Ticci Toby
-
#18 Jeff The Killer
-
#19 Pied Piper
-
#20 BEN Drowned
-
#21 Jane The Killer
-
#22 Jeff The Killer
-
#23 Candy Pop
-
#24 Laughing Jack
-
#25 Sally
-
#26 BEN Drowned
-
#27 Slender's Proxies
-
#28 Jason the Toymaker
-
# 29 Jeff The Killer
-
# 30 Bloody Painter
-
# 31 BEN Drowned
-
# 32 Puppeteer + Bloody Painter
-
# 33 BEN Drowned
-
Random
-
Random pt 2
-
# 34 Jane The Killer
-
# 35 Clockwork
-
# 36 Pastas at Christmas
-
# 36.5 Pastas at Christmas
-
# 37 What the pasta's get for Christmas
-
# 38 Pasta's New Year Resolutions
-
# 39 Jeff and Jane
-
# 40 Kagekao
-
# 41 BEN Drowned
Stories to obsess over. Discover now