Creepypasta Yaoi Lemons

Masky x Toby

Masky dominant

Toby submissive

The day started off normal, Toby annoying Masky, Masky eating cheesecake. Toby annoys Masky all the time because he has feelings for Masky. He just wants to be close to the white masked proxy.

Masky was in the kitchen eating cheesecake with Hoodie when Toby walked in. Toby sat beside Masky and watched him eat. Masky looked at Toby, "What?" He asked. Toby smirked under his mouth guard and replied with, "I have s-something to sh-sh-show you in my room! It's a-awesome c'mon!" 

Masky rolled his eyes but stood up anyways. "Alright then. I'll be back Hoodie," Masky said. Hoodie nodded as he watched Toby pull Masky out of the room. Once in Toby's room Masky asked what the surprise was. Toby locked his closed door and pushed Masky down onto his bed. "Oh M-Masky," he said taking off his goggles and mouth guard. "You r-really shouldn't of f-followed me here," He smirked.

Masky started to worry as he saw the lust in Toby's eyes. "W-What do you mean Toby?" Masky asked as he mentally cursed himself for stuttering. This made Toby smirk more. "M-Masky.. I l-love you.. and I c-can't stand it anymore! I n-need you Masky!" 

Masky was taken back by Toby's confession but smiled after the initial shock. Masky has had a crush on Toby for quite sometime. "Toby, you should of just told me," Masky said as he stood up and hugged the shaking Toby.

"W-w-what do you m-mean?" Toby asked leaning into Masky's chest. "I love you too Toby," Masky said tilting Toby's head up taking his mask off. Toby blushed and pressed his lips to Masky's. Masky immediately kissed back licking Toby's bottom lip. Toby, being inexperienced, didn't know what Masky wanted so he kept his mouth shut. Masky slid his hand to Toby's butt and squeezed it, making Toby gasp and allowing Masky to push his tongue into Toby's mouth. Toby blushed even more as a small moan came out of his mouth. 

Masky leaned back from the kiss and attacked Toby's neck. Toby moaned as Masky bit harshly on his soft spot. "M-Masky!" Toby moaned as Masky started grinding his hips into Toby's. Masky smirked against Toby's neck then pulled away and pushed Toby onto the bed, climbing in on top of him.

Masky took his and Toby's shirt off, kissing and licking Toby's nipples. Toby moaned at this attention. Masky started to unbuckle and pull Toby's pants and boxers off, slowly kissing down Toby's chest. Masky moved over to one of Toby's hips and bites it. Toby moans Masky's name. Masky smirked as he saw Toby's fully hard staff.

Toby moaned as Masky grabbed his dick and started pumping it. Masky smirked but stopped to take his own pants and boxers off. "On your hands and knees," Masky commanded Toby. Toby did as told and got on his hands and knees. Masky ducked his head towards Toby's ass and started licking and kissing Toby's hole. "M-Masky AH!" Toby moaned loudly.

Masky smirked and pushed his tongue into Toby, stroking his own dick. Once he felt Toby was lubricated enough and straitened up and rubbed his tip against Toby's hole. "D-Don't tease me M-Masky," Toby groaned, pushing his hips toward Masky. Masky chuckled and finally pushed into Toby, glad he can't feel pain. Toby moaned loudly and started rocking his hips. Masky groaned and started thrusting in and out of Toby. "AH! M-Masky! H-harder!!" Toby moaned. Masky obliged and went harder, hitting Toby's prostate. Toby moaned louder demanding Masky to go faster and harder. 

Masky thrusted harder and faster into Toby, rocking the bed. Masky moved his hand down to Toby's staff and started pumping it with his thrusts. At this point Toby was experiencing so much pleasure he started crying. "Masky! I'm close!" He moaned. "Me too!" Masky moaned in response.

Toby released onto his bed, tightening his hole against Masky's dick. Masky moaned loudly as this caused him to release into Toby. Toby collapsed onto the bed and Masky pulled out of him, laying besides him out of breath. Toby curled into Masky's side drifting to sleep. "I-I love you M-Masky, " he yawned. "I love you too, Toby," Toby heard from Masky as they both fell into a deep sleep.