Wendy, Kyle and Craig all bond over space.
Wendy, Kyle, Bebe, Red, and some others bond over beauty gurus (Jeffree Star, James Charles, etc).
Instead of abusing Kyle for being gay, he gets kicked out and he stays with Kenny.
Kyle's the nerd, Ken's the perv, Stan's the quarterback, Eric's the kid no one likes.
The quarterbacks are decent hecking people, and try to 'help' out the needy kids to come out their shell, which accidentally makes them recede further inside their shell.
Butters isn't one of those 'pastel innocent uwu' kids that you must 'protect'. He and Tweek can both stand up for themselves, they just chose not to.
Next time....
I mean, Kyman headcanons I guess.