Dean
Cutie-Pie: he calls you that because he loves four things, pie, Sam, you and baby a.k.a. the Impala.
Sam
Deer Heart: Because usually he gets called moose he figured that you should have an animal name. Plus he says you stole his heart.
Castiel
Dove: He says that if your wings would be white and delicate like a dove.
Crowley
Queen: Since he's the king that has to make you queen!
Gabriel
Sugar: Since he loves anything sweet and you met when you took a bite out of his candy bar he thought you were sweet.
Lucifer
Rose: Its his favorite flower.Michael
Angel Eyes: He loves the color of your eyes. Plus he says you're the Angel in his life.
YOU ARE READING
Supernatural Preferences
FanfictionReading situations like you are the person he loves.