Supernatural Preferences

You're a hunter...

Dean

  A demon had Dean, Sam and you tied up in a room. He had tortured all three of you showing his obsidian eyes. Dean and Sam were worried that you had no clue what was going on, but you knew.

     "The infamous (Y/N), the killer of my brother. Then the Winchesters, just natural killers." The demon said.

  Sam and Dean looked at you in shock.

     "You're a hunter?" Dean asked surprised.

     "Yes she is. Famous to all supernatural creatures, but nothing to hunters, except for Bobby Singer.

     "I bet your brother screamed like a girl with that holly water." Dean said trying to distract him.

  You got loose and you stabbed the demon with the blade you pickpocketed from Dean. When you got to the motel he had you explain everything to him. After your life story he kissed you and said,

     "I'm awesome because I'm dating a kick ass hunter."

Sam

  You and Sam bought a night in a motel. All of a sudden the lights started to flicker and you turned on your hunter senses. You made a ring of salt.

     "Where did you learn to do that?" He asked suspicious.

    "Well I may or may not be a hunter of the supernatural." You said.

    "You are now telling me this?" He said.

  

    "Well...let's just get rid of it before it gets rid of us, got it." You said.

    "This conversation is not over." Sam said.

You nodded and continued to kill, but when it was all over he and you had a long talk about being a hunter.

Castiel

He was shocked when he saw you cut off the head of a vampire, more shocked you even knew how to kill it. He started asking questions about why didn't you tell him.

   "(Y/N), why didn't you tell me?" Castiel asked concerned.

   "I didn't think it was important." You replied.

   "Of course it's important. I love you and I would like to know the real you." He returned, stunning you with his blazing grace blue eyes.

Crowley

He wasn't surprised, but he was a little bit mad. He was concerned about you and his demons. Most hunters don't get along with the supernatural.

    "Just don't kill me, okay?" he joked.

    "I'll try." You returned lovingly.

Gabriel

He was a little bit mad, so he put you in a alternative reality where you had to kill things like teddy bears to get out. It was his way of lashing out. You were okay with that.

Lucifer

He left for a while to torture souls. He wouldn't talk to you for a few days.

Michael

He took it well, in fact he loved the idea of it.