Creepypasta Yaoi stories 18+

A night to remember (Jeff x Ben)

        Ben walked into the home that Jeff and him shared. Ben stepped through the door and there sitting on the couch cleaning the blood off his knife was Jeff. Ben blushed as he saw his friend sitting there shirtless, packing a six pack and wearing low riding black skinny jeans. Ben liked Jeff and wanted him more than a friend. But how could he tell Jeff that he liked him more than that. He didn't want to get rejected much less lose the friendship which he loved having as he knew it would never go as far as he wanted.  So he walked past Jeff with his head hanging low as tears started to form in his eyes. He went into his room and laid his hat on the hook that was by his door and he went and laid in bed crying to himself. Jeff heard Ben crying and wondered what was wrong with him. Jeff secretly liked Ben, but was just as afraid to ruin their friendship as Ben was. He set his knife on the table and got up and knocked on Ben's door."Ben can I come in". Ben didn't say anything so Jeff just opened the door to see Ben sitting with his knees up to his face crying into his arms. Jeff walked over to Ben feeling sorry for his friend and asked what was wrong.

"Ben bud whats wrong"

"I don't wanna talk about it Jeff you wouldn't understand"

"I will understand Ben we are best friends why wouldn't I"

"You would hate me if I told you"

"No I won't Ben just tell me"

"NO"

"Ben please"

"NO JEFF"

"Ben Drowned you tell me why your upset right now"

"NO JEFF I DON'T WANT YOU TO GET MAD AT ME IF I TOLD YOU THAT I WANT YOU MORE THAN A FRIEND".

         Jeff stood there shocked at what Ben had said. He didn't know Ben liked him more than a friend. Ben looked up at Jeff to him just staring at him. Ben started crying blood again and now it was worse. He did it he really ruined their friendship Jeff will probably never want to talk to him again. Just as Ben looked up Jeff lunged at him kissing him passionately on his soft lips. They were so in sync with each other that both of them started moaning into the kiss. Ben felt something in the lower part of his body move, but he didn't care he was finally happy. Jeff licked Ben lower lip asking for entrance and Ben declined teasing Jeff. But Jeff put his legs on either side of Ben and started grinding on Ben making him moan letting Jeff's tongue enter his mouth. Jeff explored Ben's mouth and then he pulled away with only a string of saliva attaching them together.

"Jeff I've always liked you since the day you moved in with me I was just scared that you would reject me if I told you"

"I've felt the same Ben, but shut up and take your shirt off".

         Ben took his shirt off and began kissing Jeff again. Jeff moved one arm around Ben's waist and the other on his back and he flipped them over so Ben was sitting on his lap. Jeff then started to kiss Ben down his neck leaving love bites on him. Ben held back the moans he wanted to let out so bad, but Jeff noticed."Ben let the moans out you sound so damn sexy when you moan" Ben blushed,but still kept quiet. Then Jeff moved down and started licking and sucking on Ben nipples that were now hard and then finally Ben let out a long moan that made Jeff laugh. "AHHHH...Jeff more please" Ben begged as he knew where he wanted Jeff to go. Jeff flipped them over again,but this time he laid Ben on his back.Jeff pulled Ben's pants off and threw them on the floor. He grabbed Ben's cock and Ben wanted him to move his hand ,but when he asked Jeff to move his hand he told him to beg for it. "Jeff please move your hand and make me feel good please Jeff your the greatest Killer I've ever met please move your  hand". Jeff smirked as Ben begged and soon started moving his hand. Ben moaned loud and eventually started yelling Jeff's name. "JEFFF...P..PL..PLEASE ...GO FASTER,,,,,I'M NOT...GONNA..HOLD ..MUCH..LONGER." Jeff moved faster and soon enough Ben came on his stomach. Jeff leaned down and licked it off of Ben and then he took two fingers and told Ben to suck them. After Ben sucked them Jeff pushed Ben's legs open and put them at Ben's entrance. He stuck his fingers in Ben and Ben went crazy. "DAMN BEN YOUR TIGHT I DON'T KNOW IF I WILL BE ABLE TO FIT" He teased Ben and then he added three fingers into Ben. Finally Jeff pulled out of Ben and Ben looked at him as to tell him not to stop. "Listen if you want more you're gonna have to please me if you want more." Ben scrambled up and crawled over to Jeff pushing him on his back and quickly unzipping Jeff's jeans to reveal Jeff's cock. Ben gasped at how big it was, but pushed that to the side and began sucking on Jeff. "DAMNNNN BEN I DON'T KNOW IF THIS IS THE FIRST BLOW JOB YOU'VE GIVEN , BUT YOU'RE GOOD" Jeff threw his head back and grabbed onto Ben's hair and pushed the little elf down lower onto his now erect cock. Ben gagged as Jeff was a little to far in his mouth. Soon Jeff came in Ben's mouth and he swallowed it all. Then Ben laid on his back and Jeff prepared himself at Ben's entrance. Ben was scared since it was his first time, but Jeff assured him that he would go easy on him. Jeff pushed inside of Ben and Ben had tears running down his cheeks from the pain,but then he told Jeff to move. With each thrust Ben would moan louder and louder. Soon Jeff kept hitting Ben's sweet spot and Ben was screaming from pleasure. "OH MY GOD JEFF YES RIGHT THERE" "OH YOU LIKE THAT DON'T YOU" Jeff stopped moving just to tease Ben. "Don't stop Jeff keep going" Jeff leaned down by Ben ear and in a seductive voice he said. "I want you to scream my name loud" Jeff then thrusted hard inside of Ben making Ben arch his back. Ben screamed Jeff's name at the top of his lungs and then he felt Jeff pulsing inside of him. Jeff came inside of Ben and then Ben came. Jeff collapsed beside Ben and Kissed him passionately.

"I love you Ben"

"I love you too Jeff".

        It was a memorable night for both guys. They curled up together Jeff put his head in the crick of Ben's neck and both smiled before falling asleep. Tonight was defiantly a night to remember.

        THE END