The Fnaf Case | Matpat x OC

What now?

(A|N: Before you say something, yes, that is a picture of Katniss Everdeen from the Hunger games. I just wanted to give you an example for our dear Katherine Lily Sharp. She looks like Nate, but also a bit like Katniss with black hair and black eyes. Or, if you are more confident with that, imagine Nate as a female. You know then how she looks as well.)

„PLEASE WHAT?!", yelled the Irishman with green hair. Everyone in the room rolled with their eyes, even Chica seemed to be annoyed. 

„Could you please stop yelling?", asked Mark annoyed, „That won't fix our problems." 

„Oh, sorry", said, a now very shy, Séan and sat down on the couch. 

„Thank you", whispered Katherine and sat up. Her hair was a bit messy, but at least she was awake and not crying anymore. 

As she started to speak, her voice was strong and calm: „First off, I'm sorry that we all have to meet under these horrible circumstances. But it's very serious. We know that Nate has been kidnapped and maybe even killed by someone. We don't know who it was or what he wants, but I think that he wants to copy the murders of Purple guy." 

„How did you come up with that?", asked Stephanie. 

„It's very simple when you look at it. First he called me Henry in the first phone call. The first victim of the murders was Henry's daughter. But I don't have a daughter, so he must have meant someone else. Someone who is like a child for me or that we're both relatives, I don't know exactly. That's why he took Nate. Nate is... in some way...Henry's daughter Charlotte." 

Matthew, Mark, Jack and Stephanie gasped, before Kate continued speaking, a bit more shaky: „After we had looked for him, Phone guy has texted me. The message was: „One down, five to go." That can only mean that he wants to produce the murders. He has killed the puppet, alias Charlotte, alias Henry's daughter, alias Nate. Who comes next? The five slaughtered children. Chica, Foxy, Freddy, Bonnie and Golden Freddy. And as far as I put together the puzzle pieces...he means us." 

„So we are just children for him?!", asked Markiplier furios. 

Matthew shook his head and said: „Katherine is right, as far as I've heard it. But we aren't just children for him. We are objects or pieces on a chest board, designed to play around. And now, when he already got Nate, we have to find him. No matter what." 

Everyone nodded, before Jack asked: „But where do ya think could he possibly be? Los Angeles is huge." 

„Matthew, in the area around Nate's appartement, is there anywhere something like a Chuck e Cheese's?", asked Stephanie and Matt did get his laptop to google. 

„There's one...But the building has been closed a decade ago. It's probably not in a good state." 

„Did someone buy the restaurant after it was closed?", asked Kate and walked back and forth, trying to find a solution in all of this. Matt clicked again, until his eyes widened in shock. 

„What's wrong?", asked Jack and took the laptop, just to became pale as he saw the name and whispered: „It can't be..." 

„Give it to me!", said Mark and Jack handed him the laptop, shivering. Curios Stephanie and Katherine looked over Mark's shoulder, just to whisper in unison, filled with shock: „Scott Cawthon..."

Raaanng!

The phone vibrated, an unknown number on the display. Everyone looked at Katherine, who picked up, her fingers shaking as she pressed the green button. The same voice as the one in the life stream echoed through the room, every person in it was quiet. 

„Hello? Hello, hello? Oh hey! As you have probably found out by now, my dear Henry, I'm not joking. I'm very serious about what I do. But if you're hearing this, my first victim is still alive. I never intended to kill him. And I do not intend to kill anybody."

„But if you will call the police, I will. I may have played with him, so...he might be better off dead. Dead and buried. Whatever, enough of that. I want you to know, that you can always surrender. For that, the only thing you have to do...is wait. Wait inside your current location and wait for me to arrive. You can agree per text message or phone call."

„I swear, it will only hurt a second. If you don't believe me, he can tell it himself! Isn't that right, my friend?" 

Katherine froze and shock appeared one everyone's face when they heard the distorted voice of Nate, which didn't sound like him at all: „First it hurts. But then...you'll see how wonderful it is." 

„WHAT DID YOU DO TO MY BROTHER YOU BASTARD?!", yelled Katherine, the anger written on her face. 

„Oh Katherine. Oh my poor sweet Katherine. If you could just understand. But unfortunately, my time with you is almost over. Until then, see you next time." (If you did get the reference, I will always love you) 

Kate sobbed and hugged Matthew, while whispering: „What did he do?"

„He sounded like he wasn't Nate anymore", whispered Mark and Jack nodded in agreement. 

„Whatever Phone guy did to him", said Stephanie, slightly scared and sat down, „it must have broken him." 

„But we do now have enough evidence to find out who Phone guy is and where he helds Nate in capture", said Katherine, now with her strong and calm voice, „We just have to connect the dots between the pictures. We're gonna do this. Even with the rule to not call the police." 

„The police wouldn't believe us either way", murmured Jack under his breath, „They would probably think we're crazy or drunk." 

„You're irish", said Mark and smiled, „That's the same word as ‚drunk'." 

„Stop that!", interrupted Katherine, „Now it's not the time!" 

„She's right", said Matthew and stood up, „We have to take action now. Me and Katherine are gonna check out Scott Cawthon. You told me that you have contact with him?" 

„I had", murmured Katherine, „But it'll still work." 

Matt nodded and continued: „Someone has to check out that restaurant. It better be one person, so it doesn't affect that much attention." 

„I'll do that", said Stephanie. Matt hesitated, before he nodded again. 

„What shall we do?", asked Mark and Jack, nearly in unison. 

„Try to find a private detective", said Kate and her black eyes were now filled with a mysterious glamour, „Phone guy did say no police, but he said nothing about a detective." 

„What if he finds out?", asked Matthew pretty worried and looked into Katherine's eyes, „He's dangerous." 

„As long as you don't get hurt, it'll be okay", said the game developer and looked back into Matt's brown eyes, „We have to try at least. For Nate." 

Both stood there for an awkward long time, before Mark groaned and said: „Will you two kiss already?"