"When we get to the theater you're sitting in between me and Jason, ok?" Lindsey whispered to me as we drove to the theater in the back of Jason's car.
"Why?" I whispered back.
"Because we aren't talking to each other at the moment," she said as if it was obvious.
"Fine," I say casually, hiding my excitement.
Jason, Taylor, Lindsey and I were going to the theater to watch a movie because Lindsey's parents are having guests over and they don't want us around. Not that I blame them.
Jason and Taylor were in the front talking about something, I don't know what it was because I stopped listening after they said something about a soccer game. Lindsey and I were in the back looking through social media and talking.
Lindsey exclaimed at a post of a girl wearing a bralette and ripped jeans with fishnet stockings and saying only sluts wear that stuff. Then I gave her the look because she was wearing the exact same thing but the only difference was that she had a jacket on too.
I was wearing an off the shoulder crop top with jean shorts and vans. My hair was down and parted to the side. I barely had on any makeup. And yes, I was trying to get Jason to notice me, which totally worked by the way. When he saw me his eyes got wide and he coughed to try to hide his reaction.
We arrived at the theater a few minutes later and decided to watch a movie about a girl who has a secret relationship with her best friend's boyfriend. I was uncomfortable about this decision because it relates so much to me, except for the secret relationship part. I mean I slept with my best friend's boyfriend! And it didn't help that Taylor winked at me after we chose it.
We went into the room where it was showing and sat in the column on the left side by the wall because there were 4 seats there. We sat at the back. Lindsey sat by the wall, Taylor sat beside her, I sat beside him and Jason sat at the end. So I was sitting in between Taylor and Jason. I couldn't stop the heat rising in my body. By the time the previews were over, I was full-on horny.
About half an hour into the movie, during a kissing scene between the girl and her best friend's boyfriend, Jason leaned over to me.
"You know, she reminds me a lot about you," he said so quietly I could barely hear him.
Still keeping my eyes on the screen, I replied to him in a whisper.
"How?"
"You both slept with your best friend's boyfriend," he said.
My head whipped around to face him.
"How do you know that?" I asked him.
"Well, Lindsey went over to your house but you weren't there. Then she came back home and called you but you didn't pick up. Then she called Taylor because she thought he might know where you were. He didn't pick up either. And then when you came to pick her up the next day, your hair was a mess and you claimed to have been rushing because you woke up late. But I saw a purple mark on your thigh. A hickey. Then I chuckled to myself and said you were a bad girl and let you be. And no, I didn't tell her. We all have our share of secrets."
My mind tried to wrap around all the information he just said. I can't believe he knew this whole time.
Wait.
If he knew then why did he wait until now to tell me? Was this planned? No, it couldn't have been. We only watched this movie because the only other movie they were showing was Captain Marvel and we already watched it.
I slapped myself to stop overthinking so much and just answered him with the first thing i thought of.
"Are you going to?"
"Going to what?
"Are you going to tell her? I mean, she's your sister."
"I don't know. I might."
"No, please don't tell her."
"What's in it for me?"
"I don't know. What do you want? I'll do anything if it means she doesn't find out."
"Anything?"
"Yes."
"Ok. How about this?"
He leaned into my ear and i could feel his hot breath on my ear.
"You do whatever I say and she'll never know what you did," he whispered into my ear, in the most seductive way possible.
My breath hitched in my throat as thoughts started flashing through my mind:
"Take off your clothes."
"Suck my dick till I come in your mouth."
"Don't make a sound or I'll fuck you till you can't feel your legs."
"Umm ok. That doesn't sound so bad," I replied, "as long as you keep your end of the bargain."
"I'm a man of my word," he smiles at me.
I shake my head and turn back to the movie. I hope Jason makes me do all kinds of dirty things.
YOU ARE READING
My Best Friend's Brother (Discontinued)
Romance"You know, she reminds me a lot about you," he said so quietly I could barely hear him. Still keeping my eyes on the screen, I replied to him in a whisper. "How?" "You both slept with your best friend's boyfriend," he said. My head whipped around to...
