Kept Secret (Peter Parker x Male reader)

5.

It was finally time for you to come back. A lot of things happened since then. People forgot about you, as Peter said before you went home last week. For exemple there was a new guy in school. His name is Eliott, Eliott Esthan. He is a rich guy, but that didn't seem to make him bad. In fact he was really nice. He would hang out with MJ, Ned, Peter and me. He was also kinda nerdy but well, the others were too, so that was a match. Even though he was with the nerds he was kinda popular. People seemed to like him. After all he was a really nice guy. Also he invited us to his party at his apartment to celebrate his arrival in our school and to integrate himself. His party was this weekend while his parents are away.

School were the usual, boring as always. However, Peter seemed happier than usual, and also nicer than usual, you didn't believe it was possible but it happened. You also kept seeing Spiderman after school. That also made you happy and in a good mood for the days. People noticed it. Some said it was a nice change, some were confused at why you are but never answered. Well mostly your old friends asked it actually. 

Flash still bullied Peter for a while but after Eliott arrival he stopped. MJ told you that he got scarred of him because of some threats. Well that was good for him you didn't really cared much. The week went smoothly. The days were boring and long but the nights were great, since you were with the spiderhero. This night too you would wait for the spiderboy to come to you after his patrol. You would show him around your room. And play some video games, or watch some movies. You mentioned that you never saw any Star Wars, and as an harcore fan as he was he wanted to make a Star Wars marathon. But it's way too long for you to do that, even a whole night wouldn't cover all the movies. So you decided to meet up and watch one Star Wars movies every day until you saw everything. You liked it, well you think you'll never be an hardcore fan but it was still nice, and a good moment spent with the hero you liked so much. All of this felt like a dream, and you pinched yourself a few times to make sure it was real, and it was. And it felt magical. You had something special with this boy, and you loved it. You loved every single moments you had with him. 

The weekend arrived and you got prepared for Eliott's party. Because yes, you were invited, well most of the school was anyway. Eliott mentioned that you'll need a swim short as there will a pool and a jacuzzi. That was cool. You also told Spiderboy that you wouldn't be here that night, but he had plans too so it was okay. You got to the party, it was packed of people which make you a bit uncomfortable so you decied to go at the roof part of the apartment. There were still people but less. You took a cup of what seemed to be beer. You would sip a bit every so often. You looked around trying to find faces you could recognize. You saw your old friends, not bothering to talk to them. You finally recognized MJ from the crowd of people. 

"Hey, didn't think you woul be here !" You cheered. "But am I ??" She asked.

You looked at her confused as she walked away. Ookay. You then saw Ned, Peter and Eliott talking. You went to them and you all started chatting for a while. Eliott then went and asked people if they wanted to use the pool and explained that there were rooms and bathromm where we could get changed. Many poeple went away, and it was less packed. You decided that you will wait before getting changed, as a lot of people went changing, there definitely is a lot of lines of people waiting. 

After a while people started to come back and head to the pool. "Hey, you guys are up for a great time in the jacuzzi ?" Eliott asked. The people he asked all noded and we went to the jacuzzi. The group is mostly made of Eliott, Perter, Ned, random people and me. We were 8 in total. It was a bit embarassing being pressed at each other because of the lack of place. But you just decide to ignore it. After a lot of chat, someone proposed a truth or dare, one would do it and then it was thr turn of the other beside them. It was so cliché but we were kinda bored at this point. They were all doing some stupid stuffs because of dares, or telling things about themselves. Nothing too interesting. Until it went to Peter's turn. "So, truth or dare ?" some random asked to Peter. "Truth" He answered kind of hesitant. "Are you bi ?" odd question but whatever. Peter just answered yes quietly and then it was someone else's turn. In fact, one really cared much about it. You could see the boy being relieved. Somehow you were relieved too, knowing you weren't alone being bi. But you didn't expect that from him. You thought he liked girl. You actually think that he likes MJ by the way. But whatever. It was then your turn, you decided to play it safe, so you said dare. It was a huge mistake. "Y/N, I dare you to kiss Peter" the person who asked you said. What ?! No way this is happening, and why him of all people, and why this stupid bet in the first place ?! "No way !! I'm not doing it, and why him ?!" you asked furious. "We tought you liked him, after all you're like obsess with him saying all the hate how you hate him, we thought you just wanted to hide it." the person admitted. "No it's not true, besides I don't like boys." you said coldly before storming away.  

-Peter POV-

I felt my heart sink, so Y/N didn't like boys uh..? I went completely silent for a while and decided to get off of the jacuzzi. I went to get changed again, and decided to go home. After that night I came less and less to see you as Spiderman, until I didn't come for a week. I would still check on you though, I just couldn't help myself. But that special thing that I thought we had was just my imagination after all. One night as I checked on you, you noticed me, and you opened your window. "So, decided to finally come uh ?" he said a sad tone to his voice. "Where were you, I missed you.. and I was worried." you then added in a mumble. "You did..?" I asked surprised. "Of course I did, you're like my best friend ! I can't lose you." And then I heard my heart broke as you said that. I looked down. "Come in" you said. 

I decided that I would get in for some reasons. "So, what's the matter ? You seem off" you then asked after an awkward silence. "Well," I started, "there's this boy I like, the thing is, he doesn't like boys" I confessed. "Oh, I'm sorry." you said. After a while and another awkard silence you decided to ask really interested "Who is this boy ?" "I.. can't tell you" I said, too scared to tell you it was you, scared that I would break the last thing I had with you. "And you ? you seem troubled too" I asked too. "Well, I told people I didn't like guys while it's not true since I'm bi, and kinda stormed off, so I basically lied to my friend, and I feel bad about it." "Really ? Well maybe you should tell them and apologize" I softly said, smiling to myself, as it turnes out, I still had a chance with you. "I hope it'll work out" I admitted. You simply nodded. "Well I gotta go, see you tomorrow then ?" I asked. "With pleasure" you simply responded. Then I waved at you as I always does before swinging back to aunt May's apartment.