Shaylivia Smut

Three's A Crowd

Olivia wants to share Shayne

She was terrified, to say the least. Olivia was shaking as she approached Courtney's apartments, the soles of her shoes hitting the ground mysteriously in the silent night. The streetlamps shone brightly on her in black sweatpants and a grey hoodie. She was genuinely scared for the first time in her life. She was going to ask, beg, something of Courtney and Shayne. Half of her, the rational side, hoped they would say no and turn away. The other part of her intensely longed for the images that plagued her mind every night. It wasn't like she hadn't brought up something crazy before. It was practically normal at this point to suggest something to her friends. They expected it. This time was different though and Olivia wasn't sure Courtney was going to be okay with it. Shayne either. God, everything was so confusing with anxiety wracking her and clouding her vision. She had texted Courtney earlier and told her to meet on the sidewalk. Olivia didn't want anyone thinking anything suspicious though that was probably what this meeting would be.

Olivia tapped her toes nervously as she awaited the blonde to step out into the night. Her eyes lingered on the door though she checked to make sure no one was watching. Why would they, though? It's around ten and cold due to oncoming winter. The only realistic passersby would be dog owners and their cute little dogs. With a slight creak, Olivia's heart dropped. Courtney was opening her door and rushing out with a coat pulled around her body. She looked nice; her hair short and flushed around her face. It was something Olivia generally liked to see but tonight was an exception. She just wished Courtney would stop walking toward her with casual steps and with her even more casual smile that lit up the darkness.

"What's up Olivia?" Courtney asked.

She stuffed her hands in her pockets and tilted toward Olivia. 

"You wanna go somewhere or something? I can't tonight but you could have just texted and asked instead of coming all the way out here and-" Courtney began,

"Courtney shut up" Olivia said. 

Olivia flushed a slightly pink and let out a breath she didn't know she had been holding. 

"I wanna ask you something-" Olivia said.

Courtney was about to speak but Olivia put a finger up to her soft lips and shushed her. Olivia savored the feeling of her lips as she let her hand fall and smiled as genuinely as she could muster. She just couldn't smile happily as she felt like puking from anxiety.

"Would you have a threesome with Shayne and me?" Olivia blurted out.

She stepped back to give Courtney some space. She was a paper white color that worried Olivia. Though she let Courtney be, let her have some time to cool and most important process the words that come out of her mouth. Inside Courtney felt like a fucking tornado had erupted in her chest. It was a mixture of excitement, adrenaline, and surprise. Maybe some curiosity in there. No, a lot of curiosity. She had so many questions that she knew would need to be answered. As much as she wanted to spew all of the feelings inside of her, she only said one word that didn't summarize anything.

"Why?" Courtney asked.

Olivia stopped breathing. 

Why? 

Why was the right question and she had no idea to answer it. She just wanted it, needed both of them like the air that filled her lungs. She longed for the pleasure and everything she would feel with both of them. It was sick and twisted and weird. Olivia was just so glad Courtney hadn't run away by now and let her explain herself at least. If shame wouldn't destroy her in the next few weeks, the pain would if Courtney had left by now.