Anything But Typical

Yoko Ono

ALT TITLE: What should've happened at the track party.

"I don't know Newton," Izzie sends Casey a smirk, "looks like enemy territory."

"Tonight we dance with them, tomorrow we crush them." Casey sends back a happy grin.

Izzie nods, agreeing. "It does look kinda fun."

"Oh shoot I forgot you hate fun though. So maybe," Casey continues talking even as Izzie grabs her hand and drags her to dance, "we just go back to the room and study something, anything!"

Izzie laughs and pulls Casey along, finally reaching their destination. Casey is immediately pulled in to dance and Izzie tries to relax and have fun. Watching Casey in that crop top wasn't helping her internal Gay Panic©.

After a few minutes, the bass of a different song starts. Izzie doesn't recognize it, but Casey's face changes instantly. She knows the song and she likes it. Instead of dancing with her friends, she moves closer to Izzie.

I don't wanna take from you

Casey dances slowly, just trying to coax her (girlfriend? best friend? secret gay lover?)... whatever Izzie was out of her shell.

I don't need an IOU

Izzie is receptive to Casey, and she can feel her body begin to heat up just by looking at the other girl. She moves closer to Casey, and laughed slightly when Casey goes around behind her.

Keep your pockets superglued
I got nothin, you got nothin

Casey finally comes around to face and and moves to where there's only inches of space between them.

Be my Yoko Ono muse

Casey allows her lips to fall towards Izzie's ear and whispers those words to her. For a moment, panic crosses Izzie's face and Casey almost takes a step back in anticipation of being pushed away.

I got nothin, you got nothing

But Izzie surprises her and pulls her closer with her hands on her waist. Casey grins and lets her arms fall onto Izzie's shoulders as the two move together as if they'd been dancing for decades.

All I wanna spend is one more night
Between these sheets, behind your eyes

"You know," Izzie whispers, "if you want to spend time between some sheets we can do that."

Casey freezes, but only for a second. "I mean who in their right mind would turn that down?" She presses her forehead against Izzie's, wondering if the other girl was actually serious.

Izzie leans up on her tiptoes and kisses Casey, taking them both by surprise. Nobody else at the party even bats an eye, and Izzie's internalized homophobia shrinks a little.

Without warning Casey breaks the kiss and grabs Izzie's hand, pulling her towards the door.

A few of her old Newton teammates whistle and say some crude things, but neither girl is listening.

They're a foot in the door when Casey attaches her lips to Izzie's, tasting the watermelon frozen yoghurt they'd had after dinner. With a grunt, she picks her up and carries her to the bed.

Izzie stares up at her with dark eyes, leaning back on her elbows and breathing heavily. "Well Newton, come and get it."

And Casey does. It takes a couple minutes to get both their sets of clothes off, but when she accomplishes that she pushes Izzie further up on the bed and crawls after her.

Their lips attach again and again, both too nervous for a kiss to last very long. Casey presses her lips to Izzie's neck, easily finding the sweet spot below her ear. Izzie's moan in response almost sends Casey over the edge right there.

Casey seems to take years to kiss her way down Izzie's body, but when she makes it to her destination Izzie's hands tighten in her hair and her thighs try to suffocate her in their heaven.

"Casey, fuck, baby I need you." Izzie had always been vocal with what she wanted, and she wasn't about to stop now.

Casey pauses momentarily. Izzie has never called her 'baby' before and the sound of it made her giddy. "Are you sure? We can stop if you want."

"Please fuck me."

That's all Casey needed to hear. She swipes her tongue through Izzie's folds once, barely holding back a moan at the taste, unfamiliar yet all she ever needed. She wraps her lips around Izzie's clit and sucks softly, before pushing a finger into Izzie's entrance.

"Fuck!" Izzie's loudness was probably going to alert all their teammates to their activities, but neither girl cared much. "Harder Casey."

And Casey complies, pushing the finger in and out faster, and then adding a second. It only takes a few minutes before Izzie's walls are tighter than ever and her curses are coming more frequently.

"Casey," she moans her name, "oh my God I'm-." She reaches her climax before finishing her sentence. "Fuck I love you so much."

Both girls freeze, Casey still had cum dripping down her chin. She swipes her hand across her mouth and leans up to take Izzie's lips into a long kiss.

"I love you too Iz." She falls on her back next to Izzie. "More than you'll ever know."

Izzie, still a little shaken from that mind blowing orgasm, climbs on top of Casey. "Let me show you how much you mean to me."

Casey smirks and gestures between her legs. "Show away."

With a slight laugh at her lover's dorkiness, Izzie begins making her way down, spending ample time on Casey's chest and hips. "This is going to sound crazy but I really love your hips."

Casey groans at the tensions already building. "That's great, but could maybe move on please?"

Izzie snorts. "I'm trying to be romantic here babe. But fine, if you want to be impatient," she cuts herself off and dives in.

—

Breakfast the next morning was an awkward affair. Casey and Izzie spent their time avoiding the glare of their coach and trying to discreetly massage the soreness out of their thighs.

And yet somehow, they take first and second place in their race, and then another first place in the team event.

They're the talk of the school for a few day, and Izzie feels anxious the whole time but she doesn't run. She sticks with Casey and Casey sticks by her. It all works out, and before the week is over the gossip train had moved along to the next station.

Authors Note

Hey y'all!

sorry i haven't posted in a while. if you're here from my Camren one shot book, you know that i'm in college and had finals and then had to spend a month with my family, so i was a bit distracted.

speaking of the Camren one shot book, i just posted a new story so if you like Camila and Lauren, you should check it out.

thanks so much for reading!!

as always, prompts are welcomed and encouraged. let me know what else y'all would like to see.

i also have an xfactor and a "you only see color when you fall in love" story in the works, so let me know which one you would like to see first.

have a great day/ week/ month/ year/ DECADE!!!

- Penny