Creepypasta One-Shots

Ben Drowned x Shy!Reader (Part Two)

Intended for mature audiences, read at your own discretion

     "I'm going to make sure I'm your first everything, my beautiful love."

     He looked up at you from your neck, those sparkling blue eyes full of adoration. He shifted to hover just above you, his eyes boring into yours with an intensity that took your breath away. And then it seemed like a trance had been broken as he suddenly leaned back, still straddling your waist but no longer running his hands along your body or dragging sounds out of you that you didn't know you could make. You sat up quickly, fearful that you did something wrong without knowing it.
    He runs a hand through his hair, a look of frustration and longing painting his gorgeous face. He let out a long suffering sigh before leaning back down to drop his head against your shoulder, one of his arms reaching underneath you to wrap around your waist. You shakily brought your arms up to rest around his shoulders, drawing slow circles between his shoulder blades. "Did I do something wrong? If I did, I didn't mean to, I swear. I don't really know what I'm-" he cuts you off by nuzzling into your neck and placing a soft kiss against your jawline.
    "No, you didn't do anything sweet Y/N. My boss just decided to let me know that I'm needed for work way sooner than he originally told me for tonight." He leans back again, the arm under your waist pulling you up with him as he adjusted your positions to set you sideways in his lap, one hand resting gently against your thighs. He softly pulled your head to lean against his chest as he leaned back against the headboard, another one of those sighs leaving his lips before he rested them against your forehead.
    "I suppose it's for the best though, I got a little carried away in your beauty and was about to defile you without even taking you out to dinner first. That's not very gentlemanly at all. Not to mention your parents must be worried sick at the moment." You had completely forgotten about everything else outside of your encounter with Ben, most importantly your homework and the "home" waiting for you. Ben felt you tense up at the mention of your parents, and curl closer into his chest, as though you didn't want to think about that. He removed his hand from your thigh and gently lifted your face by your chin, looking into your eyes with the same intensity that had been taking away your breath all night.
    "Do you not want to go home? You kind of tensed up when I mentioned your parents." You shook your head, figuring that considering what's happened tonight already, surely you can trust him with this. "My father took off when I was little, and Mother blames me for it. She isn't really the nicest if she notices me in her areas of the house." You weren't allowed to be outside of your bedroom if she wasn't in hers, making it hard for you to go into even the kitchen if needed. You watched as the feelings in his eyes shifted, his mouth hardening into almost a straight line as he slightly tightened his grip on you in an almost protective way. He shook his head, letting go of your chin to wrap his arms around you and pull you flush against him, your head tucked under his chin.
    "I know this may seem very sudden considering we just met tonight, but I have an extra bedroom here that I can clear all of my gaming stuff out of if you maybe, wanted to move out of your mother's? It's a quiet area, and you don't have to if you're uncomfortable with it and I completely unders-" you cut him off by pressing your lips against his, one of your hands coming up to cradle your face. He melted beneath you, his hands trying to pull you closer to him, as though he couldn't get you close enough. You adjusted your position to be straddling his lap, his hands gently resting on your hips. You broke the kiss, leaning back just enough to rest your forehead against his as your other hand that wasn't cupping his cheek came to rest on his shoulder.
    "I think I'd maybe like that. But we'd have to figure out everything, like my job and my school and-" you stopped yourself mid-sentence to lean back and look around frantically. "Have you seen my backpack? I could've sworn I had it but I don't remember bringing it here, I was so distracted in the alley, and then we were just suddenly here and-" Ben cuts your rambling short by grabbing your wrist and gently turning you around to face him. "I grabbed your bag, it's in the living room. Take a deep breath for me." He softly bumped his forehead against yours.
    "Thank you." His other hand came up to tuck a strand of hair behind your ear, resting against your cheek. You could feel his breath against your lips, and your cheeks flushed, suddenly hyperaware of how intimate he's been with you all evening, and it suddenly crashing into you that you would be living here with him. You bring one of your hands up to lightly grip his wrist, leaning back to make eye contact. "Are you sure you're okay with offering for me to move into your spare room? I mean, we just met tonight and while it would be super nice to finally get out of that house, I wouldn't wanna bother you or get in your way, and I could pay-" he cuts you off with a finger against your lip, his crimson eyes almost shining with how intense they were, boring into your own. "If I wasn't sure, I wouldn't have offered it." He cracked a soft half smile, slightly tilting his head and causing his hair to shift, it's blonde color catching the dim candlelight in the room. "And I don't want to hear a word about paying anything. You'll live here rent free, so you can worry about other things. I'm not using the spare room for anything important, so it's all yours."
    His hand slid down to grip your own, pulling you back over to sit in his lap on the bed, his arms cradling you once more as he kisses the top of your head. "Now, I've gotta get going to work, but I can either take you back to your mother's right now, or we can wait until I get back home, and I can go with you. You're free to sleep here, I should only be gone for a few hours." As if on cue, you yawned, the events of the night suddenly making your eyes heavy. You snuggle into his chest, his body suddenly very warm and cozy. His whisper is muffled against your hair, "I guess that settles that then. Get some good sleep for me my beloved, I'll be back before you know it."
    He tucks you into the bed, your consciousness swiftly fading into sleep as he puts out all of the candles but one. You vaguely hear the door shut, your eyes closing with a soft smile on your face as you dream of a intense pair of red eyes watching over you.

Hey! Sorry it's been a long time since I updated! But a quick question! Do you guys want to see more of how this storyline plays out with Ben, or do we leave it here? Comments are very much appreciated! 🖤