Chapter 5

7.5K 291 249
                                    

"Not at all." He repeated. "Oh.. Well some people tease me about it." I chuckled it off. "I want to know more." I looked over at him. Since that was kind of random.
"M-more?" I asked. "Yeah. You seem.. Gee how do I put this.. Interesting." The tone behind his voice kind of scared me. "Oh well um." He sat on my bed. I moved over next to him and then turned to face him. "Slendy found me when I was three. I fell down a hill type thing, my dad killed my mother.. I'm pretty sure the drunk is still alive today." I got lost in thought. Then Toby snapped me back to reality. "Oh I'm so sorry." He said in a hushed tone. I looked at him. "Toby can I see your face?"
"You're looking at it."
"OH GEE IS THAT WHAT THAT IS- no I mean without your mask thing and goggles." He hesitated. "Why." He said in not a question but more of a statement. "Because you look very attractive from what I see and I want to see the rest. " I said plainly. He sat there. "No I'm sorry (Y/N), but I am so very unattractive and I don't want to scare you off." He almost chuckled. You snickered. "Toby take a good look at my face, do I look like I have much room to laugh?"
"Well I think you're beautiful." I felt my stupid face warm up again. Thanks God for making us blush. Like oh, you like this boy? Let me make you're face turn red so he knows~ "(Y/N)?" Toby brought me back into thought. "OH~ sorry lost in thought.. I have ADD. Now let me see your face.."
"Fine.. Don't laugh please. "
I half smiled.

He wasn't moving. "Well do I have to do everything myself?" I joked. I gently grabbed the sides of his goggles and lifted them on to his head. His eyes were very pretty. They where actually Hazel. "You have pretty eyes." I could see a light pink dust his face. I took his mask and slowly pulled it down. I stared at his pale face.

"You lie!" I said after a moment of stare.
"Um.."
"You are very attractive!!"

Knock, knock.

"Toby, (Y/N)?" I heard Masky's voice through the door. I got up and opened it. "Sorry to interrupt but we have a new member.. " as a proxy we kind of had to meet the new homies. "Okay." I looked back and Toby put his goggles and mask back on. That friggin' banana. (A/N: dat insult doe.) "we will be down in a sec."

A Broken Heart (Ticci Toby X Reader)Where stories live. Discover now