Lost Love for the Brown Eyed Girl

Unknown Feelings

Joey's POV

I walked out with Atem and Tea, trying to find Kathryn since we saw her walk out the back of the cafe. It was snowing more as we walked around the tall corner building to see Kathryn. Being held, by Kaiba. Their foreheads touched, I couldn't hear what they were saying, but I saw their lips moving. I was angry, disappointed, and very upset.

"Kathryn? Kaiba?" They looked over, and I saw Kathryn mumble, 'shit'. Us 3 just stood there, staring at them as my heart raced. I couldn't express how I felt seeing what was in front of me; the girl I loved and adored, being held by her ex lovingly. Was this why she said she was working late?

I approach them, with Tea and Atem following. Kaiba stepped in front of Kathryn, putting her behind him as if I would hurt her. 

"Sorry, mutt. You're too late." That nickname always struck the nerve I had deep in my soul and I hated it.

"What do ya mean, I'm too late?! Kaiba, you must be brain-washin' her!" Kaiba smirked, then laughed at me. "Kaiba! I'm not playin'.." The last sentence turned quiet, I was hurt, heart broken, thinking I would get a chance with Kathryn, and making her life so much better than how it was when they were together the first time.

"Wheeler, you'll never be good enough for her. I'll admit that I fucked up, but I thought about it. The more I did, the more I missed her." He looked back to see her and they smiled at each other. He wasn't smirking at her, he was smiling. "With the amount of times I smile at her, Wheeler," He began then turned his gaze back to me. "I'm surprised you didn't die, you puppy." 

That hit the nerve, the bigger nerve.

"WHY YOU LITTLE!" I went to him, to punch him the face. He deserved it for saying that, but I was getting held back by Atem.

"Joey! Calm down, you know he's not worth your anger." He said to me in a calming voice, but that didn't stop me from getting more mad at rich boy for taking the girl I loved away.

"Kaiba! You have no idea how much that girl means to me!" I looked behind him to see her face perk up. She was shocked I said that, but Kaiba puts an arm around her. 

"What do oyu mean, Joey?" Kathryn asked, narrowing her eyebrows at me.

"I loved you." I finally admitted it. The lump in my throat grew, tears were coming. I was so frustrated and I couldn't help but let it out. "I did a whole lot for you." Her eyes widened as I continued to speak. "Serenity loved seeing you, she looked up to you." I looked down and kicked the snow to the side. "I was too afraid to say it before because I wanted it to be a special moment, this is not what I had in mind." Her eyes were locked on mine, not moving at all. 

"Why? Why wouldn't you say that before?" She got out as she sighed in irritation.

"Because I didn't want it to be too soon!" Kathryn scoffed and waved her hand at me. 

"Joey, I did like you. I did, but I began to miss Seto. Despite the shit he has done; like cheating and threatening to kick you out of the city. A piece of me still loved him." She got a gentle hold of his hand, signalling me that she is going with him. "I called him, after I sent you the text." She said with her head down, knowing she was going into a guilt trip. "I told him I wanted to meet with him today, and I knew you wouldn't like me seeing him."

"Damn right I wouldn't! So, you did lie to me!" I shouted to her, obviously not the happiest. 

"I did lie, Joey. But, we're not even together so it's not like you can tell me what I can and cannot do. Seto hasn't even done that when we were together the first time. Now, this tells me something about you." She looked up at Kaiba, and tugged his hand while smiling. "Can we get going? I'd love to see Mokuba; I'm sure he would love to see me, too."

Kaiba kissed her. He lifted her head up so gently and gave her a kiss, knowing it would irritate me even more. The girl I loved is back with him, I haven't felt this broken since Serenity's surgery for her blindness. I felt my warm tears streaming down my face as I saw them get into Kaiba's car. I was just so broken, I had no idea how else to describe how I felt, pieces of my heart fell to the pit of my stomach as Atem and Tea try to comfort me. 

Kathryn's POV

I gripped on Seto's hand as he drove his car through Domino, heading to his company. I felt a little bad for hurting Joey's feelings, but I don't regret it. It was the truth, that I missed Seto. It couldn't be helped. 

"Hey, can we stop at Tea's really quick? It's around the next block."

"I know where the geek squad cheerleader lives, but why?" 

"I'd like to pick up my belongings, she probably plans on kicking me out when she gets back anyway for hurting Joey's feelings." Seto gave me an irritating sigh. 

"We have to make it quick. Mokuba is taking my place in a meeting today so I could run to the store. Let's hurry.

20 minutes later...

I loaded up my clothes and gifts for Seto and Mokuba in the back of his car, and I left the other gifts for everyone else on the freshly made bed, not wanting or even needing to bring them with me. Seto has helped me load up everything, but I noticed there was so many bags from the store he went to, but he wouldn't let me look in the bags.

"Kathryn, let's get to my company. You have my little brother waiting for you after the meeting." He said as we closed the trunk of the car. I nodded and quickly got into the passenger side, buckling up and getting ready to head on over. 

Here's the update!