~Angel~ |AOT x SDS!Reader|

Cheating (Alternative ending) |Extended story oneshot|

Alternative ending
•I wanted to add this in just cause, I figure it could be fun to have this ending instead of the usual one that I'm having for the one shot story. I might branch out and do more stories with this ending as well. I'll make sure that they're labeled though•
This isn't cannon to the actual storyline ^-^

(Y/n) POV
"Its a promise ring, for now since I can't ask you to forgive me I wanted to give you something that'll show you I mean what I said."
He ushered me to give him my hand, I did reluctantly and the ring fit.
"Thanks."
Was all I could really muster to say right now, I still could barley look at Levi.
I knew it was a mistake but how does someone do that and then try to make up for it with a stupid gift.
Sure his speech was nice and he can apologize better then Ban or Meliodas but still.
"I'm going to just go for a while."
I said turning to Hanji and Erwin and walking with them back to the barracks.
"I'm sorry (y/n) I should've done something, I was there with him but I was too drunk to even see straight."
Erwin basically pleaded, it sounded like he was the one that cheated on me.
I giggled internally at the thought.
"Don't be, if he wanted to cheat then I'm glad it came out sooner rather than later."
I sighed as Hanji left to grab something from the kitchen.
"Erwin has this ever happened to you? I'd be surprised if it has."
I smiled weakly to try and make it seem like I wasn't still feeling numb inside.
"It has, my late wife did at one point."
"How'd you forgive her?"
"It took time, I still barley forgave her by the time she passed."
"I find it surprising she would, you're one of the few guy humans I actually enjoy talking with."
I looked up at him to see his cheeks flush red as Hanji came back holding two bottles of alcohol.
"Well if we're going to be a pitty party might as well drink to it."
She said with fake enthusiasm plaguing her tone.
The cadets were all going back to their dorms now so it was fine for us to drink.
"Can we go to your lab or your office? I'd rather not be around people if I'm going to be drunk."
I said quietly as they both nodded, we started to head over to Erwins office.
It was a big office so I figured it would be nicer than Hanji's messy lab.
We opened the door and all sat down, Erwin and I were on the couch and Hanji was sitting next to me in a separate chair.
She poured 3 shots and handed one to us.
"Cheers to bad life decisions!"
She still was trying super hard not to sound sad or annoyed and it was easy to tell.
We all downed the shots, she poured more and we just all kept taking them.
I felt bad for Erwin since he was drunk as hell yesterday and now he's taking more, he didn't protest the idea but it seemed like he was going to be a wreck tomorrow.
"So what are we going to do now?"
I took another shot since I was barley drunk compared to both of them.
"Not sure! Almost every conversation would probably lead to depressing shit so let's just roll with it!"
Hanji said as she slumped down in her chair.
"Hanji I asked Erwin before, but have you ever been cheated on?"
"I haven't dated for a reason (y/n), maybe when I was a cadet but I barley remember it."
She giggled at her own words now, I was still basically chugging the whole bottle at this point since being a goddess makes alcohol taste like nothing.
"I'm still surprised Levi would do that, he's always been a very cut and dry man since he tried to kill me."
Erwin said, Hanji was probably the most drunk out of all of us, Erwin only seemed a bit tipsy.
"He tried to kill you?"
"When he joined yes, it was a long time ago."
"Well tell me Commander, how was he when he was a cadet then?"
I giggled seeing him sit up and think for a moment.
"About as rude as he is now, only difference is that he can bark orders with permission."
He chuckled lowly as I joined in giggling, Hanji basically passed out on the chair.
"Oh yea where am I sleeping tonight? I don't want to go back to Levi's room."
I said, it was getting past dinner by now and we had all been talking for quite some time.
I figured Ban, Meliodas, and Gloxina had gone home already.
"You're welcome to sleep in my room, I know it probably will be uncomfortable for you but I feel like it's better."
Erwin said plainly, I honestly wasn't even sure if he was still drunk.
"I'd be alright with that I just don't want to sleep in the same bed as Levi for a while, I can't get the thought of him sleeping with Petra from my head."
"It's alright."
He said as we both stood up and walked through a door connecting to his office that lead to his bedroom.
He sat down and stripped off his clothes until he was on boxers then he slid on sweatpants like Levi.
He sat down on the bed as I laid down and started dozing off looking at the ceiling.
"(Y/n)?"
He snapped me from my thoughts as I noticed I had drawn blood on my hand, I was squeezing it so hard I pierced myself with my nail.
"S-sorry yea?"
"We should have that patched up if you don't want to heal it."
"I don't know if I want to or not, hell I had my friends also beat the shit out of me and that barley did anything."
I closed my eyes and felt Erwin grab my hand, he kissed it and wiped off the blood so it wouldn't drip.
"I understand, I'm still sorry that this happened to you. You're a goddess after all I figure that's More of a human problem."
He chuckled softly to himself, I just smiled and relaxed into the pillows.
"Maybe, all the other couples in the sins aren't human so I wouldn't know."
"They arent?"
"No, Ban is dating a fairy, and Meli is dating a goddess. Gowther dated a human for a while but that was mind control so I don't count it."
I sighed slightly thinking about how that whole ordeal happened.
"Mind control? Well that's certainly one way to get a woman into bed."
"Oh he didn't even want to sleep with her, he literally can't cause he's a doll."
"Your world is fascinating (y/n)."
He chuckled as he looked at me I kept smiling since it was true, our worlds were so different.
"Commander?"
"Yes?"
"Can you indulge me with something?"
"What is it?"
I smirked as I pulled him into a kiss, he seemed surprised at my actions since he didn't kiss back immediately.
He eventually melted into the kiss and pulled me closer to him, I scratched the back of his neck before moving up to his hair to pull him closer to me.
"No one has to know what we do."
I smiled against his lips as he growled and pulled me on top of him.
I shifted on his hips as he moved his hands to rub my sides.
"You're alright with this?"
He said, his voice was rough it sounded like he had wanted this for a long time, he was desperate now.
"I said indulge me Commander."
I purred as I pulled him into a heated kiss once again, his hands slid under my dress before he pulled it off me.
He kissed down my neck and began sucking on my nipples.
"A-ah~ fuck~"
I whimpered as he smiled against me before sucking harder, he pulled off and pressed me down on my back.
His lips moved down so they were kissing around my panties.
"You're such a tease~"
I complained as he just smirked up at me.
"Who said I didn't want to have some fun with this."
He said between kisses before he pulled down my panties and ran his tongue across my slit.
"F-fuck m-more please~"
"As you wish~"
His lips started sucking around my clit as he slid two fingers inside me and started pumping.
"You're so tight, I don't know how I'll fit inside you."
He chuckled softly seeing me squirm in front of him.
"I-can take it p-please~"
I watched as he pulled his fingers out and licked them clean before pulling down his sweatpants and boxers.
He pressed his tip against my slit and pushed in slowly.
"F-fuck you're so wet~"
I smiled before feeling him start fucking into me, his lips met mine to muffle my moans.
"A-ah h-harder please~"
"Begging are we? Be a good girl and rub you clit for me~"
I moved my hand down to touch my clit and immediately it felt like a jolt of electricity, he pushed in harder as I started to rub.
"That's it, you look so good taking all of me like a good little princess. Keep rubbing through your climax."
He smirked into my neck as he pressed kisses against it.
"Y-yes fuck y-yes~"
I could barley muster those words, I couldn't think straight.
I felt my abdomen burn as I tightened around him.
"I-I'm gonna cum~"
I whined as he moved one of his hands to pinch and pull my nipple as I came around him, I kept rubbing and I couldn't stop cumming.
"Look at your lewd little pussy, you're still cumming around me."
I blushed looking down and seeing him pounding into me with my fingers and his member covered in my cum.
His pace got sloppy as I started to get close again.
"I'm gonna c-cum again~"
"That's a good girl, cum around me~"
I did almost immediately, I felt him spill inside me soon after.
I was breathless by now, my legs were shaking and I couldn't think straight.
He pulled out and pulled up his boxers and sweatpants as he got up.
"You make quite the mess in bed."
Erwin chuckled softly as I just sighed and smiled up at him.
"I blame that on you."
I teased as he came back with a wet rag, he got between my legs and started to rub up my thighs.
I winced slightly as he smirked down at me.
"Very sensitive too I see."
"Again I blame you."
I giggled as he finished cleaning and helped me up, he got up once more and grabbed me a button up from his drawer and handed it to me.
I put it on and relaxed into the bed.
"Well I definitely didn't expect that, I thought you were too tipsy to want to do anything like that."
I admitted as he laid beside me.
"Hanji is a light weight with drinking, the alcohol she got wasn't very strong. That's why I assume you weren't drunk either."
"I'm a goddess, me getting drunk takes about half a bar."
We both laughed lightly before I felt my eyes getting heavy.
-
We both woke up early, the sun was barley up as I saw him getting ready for the day.
"Someone's up early."
I giggled as I sat up seeing him finishing putting on the leather straps for their gear.
"I can say the same to you (y/n)."
He chuckled before fixing his hair and sitting down beside me.
"You don't regret last night do you?"
He asked plainly, it was pretty obvious that he didn't regret it at all.
"I don't, if Levi takes Zelis place he'll have more than an eternity to make it up to me. I think I can have some fun for a night."
I smiled as he just nodded and stood up once again, I tried to stand up but it hurt so I just spread my wings and began to hover.
"I didn't think I was that rough with you."
He teased as I slid my dress over my head.
"That wasn't rough?"
I giggled as I relaxed in mid air.
"I was being gentle."
He smirked fixing his tie before opening the door for me.
-
We made our way to the mess hall and I felt physically ill seeing Levi and Petra was still trying to talk with him.
Erwin could definitely see the discomfort on my face so he touched my shoulder and rubbed lightly.
He walked to the table while I floated and sat down beside him and Hanji.
Levi and Petra were on the other side, along with some of the members of his squad.
Petra scoffed as I sat down, I just rolled my eyes and held my hand in a snap position.
"I suggest you don't fucking piss me off more you disgusting fucking slut. I'll kill everyone I resurrected and go home. I'll leave you and this whole fucking nation painted red for all I care."
I said blankly looking up at her as she squealed quietly, Levi looked dead, his eyes were puffy, he looked more pale that usual and his whole demeanor was barley there.
"(Y/n) it's alright."
Hanji tried to comfort me, she was very clearly hung over but she was trying.
"I'm going to go, Hanji I want to try something. Come with me."
I ushered as she stood up almost immediately and followed me out.
I heard Petra still talking as I left.
"I told you she's fucking psycho!!"
I had my hand on my thigh as I floated, I ripped a slash into my leg as we exited the mess hall, my blood dripped down on the floor as we did.
"Why did you do that (y/n)? You're bleeding like crazy!"
Hanji said noticing the slash on my leg.
"I told you I'm an irrational person, to keep myself from doing something stupid I resort to that. I can heal it easily, it's not a big deal."
I said calmly as she just looked worried the whole time that we went to the top of the wall.
There were a bunch of cadets up there for cannon duty.
"(Y/n) did that happen in the fight y-yesterday?"
Jean questioned as I flew Hanji up and set her down with them.
"No."
I didn't exactly want to talk but when he said that Eren, Armin, Mikasa, Sasha, and Connie all looked worried.
"W-where was it from?"
Armin stuttered out, he knows that I can only really be injured by a demon or a goddess.
"It's a small injury I don't care much to explain."
I said coldly, I just wanted them to leave me alone.
"Alright so what did you want to show me (y/n)?"
I sat down on the ledge as the other cadets swarmed Hanji and me, they all were confused but they stayed quiet.
"I want to see if my singing can put titans to sleep, I can change frequency to put certain creatures to sleep."
I explained as Hanji just seemed surprised while Eren sat down beside me.
I liked the kid, he had a lot of determination and reminded me of Ban when Ban wasn't here.
"Go for it (y/n) you still amaze us everyday."
He said looking off into the distance, he was so caring, I wonder how many times he's gotten hurt too.
I leaned my head on him before grabbing his hand and squeezing, he seemed surprised at this but he smiled non the less.
"Hanji just watch the titans. I can bring you another test subject if they do fall asleep."
I sighed seeing her smile at me but nod with hope in her eyes.
(Heart wants what it wants- Selena Gomez)
"You got me sippin' on something.
I can't compare to nothing.
I've ever known, I'm hoping.
That after this fever I'll survive.
I know I'm acting a bit crazy, strung out, a little bit hazy. Hand over heart, I'm praying, that I'm gonna make it out alive."