Secrets Worth Protecting Peter Pan x Reader

Friends

Y/N's POV
Peter and I have gotten... close. You could say we're friends, but I would say he's a person I have a few conversations with. We haven't gotten that close since I still don't trust him, even though he says he'll keep his promises I still don't believe him. You can understand why. He brought the boys again and they somewhat behaved, I would reward them when they would actually do something, mostly Toodles. "Hey Y/N, why not take a break from all this working?" Peter asks flying towards me "Sorry Peter, maybe next time." "That's what you keep saying every time I ask." "Not my fault." "It is, you never wanna relax and you know, chill." "When you say that, you mean bother Papa to his death." "But wouldn't you wanna at least have a break, relax your..." "Muscles, you seriously need some common knowledge." I said walking away from and walking to the stream.

Peter Pan's POV
I watched as they walked away, I just stared at their hips. I was happy with what I saw. A rock was thrown directly at me "Ow!" "Hey! Her eyes are up here! Keep your filthy hand in your own pants!" Yelled what Y/N called Terence "Woah! I wouldn't think that way, honest!" "I'm watching you womanizer." he says flying backwards pointing two fingers at his eyes, then to me. "Terence no! No death threats, bad fairy!" Tink shouts as she pulls "Terence" away from me. I then flew to where Y/N went, seeing they weren't at the stream I was now confused. I look down and see their tracks following it, so I did the same.

"Hey ladies." "Hey Y/N, how's the garden going?" "It's fine, Peter and the boys are helping, mostly Toodles. He's my favorite so he gets to have longer breaks."

Come on! How come I'm not the favorite! I flew over to where I heard the conversation and saw Y/N getting undressed!

"How are you guys doing, I heard Sofie has a crush on someone." Y/N said teasingly before getting in the water, wait! How are the mermaids letting them in the water? Wouldn't they drown him/her if they even got their clothes off!? What am I thinking?!

Y/N's POV
I was relaxing in the water, talking with the mermaids and teasing Sofie about her crush. "Well what about you and Peter, Y/N? You two seem awfully close!" I felt my cheeks heat up a bit "Excuse me what?" "You two seem awfully close since you two are working together." "I helped him, he help me, end of story." "Really then how come he is watching you right now!" Kate shouts as she points to Peter who was staring at us. I grabbed a rock and threw it at him "Ow! What was that for!?" "How long were you watching us!?" "I-I... the part where you got undressed?" I grabbed a rock that was slightly a bit bigger and threw it at him. "Ow!! Would you stop that!?" "At least I'm not a pervert! Don't you have any respect for people's privacy!?" "I'm sorry okay! Now could you stop throwing rocks at me!?" "After that stunt you pulled I think not!" I shouted back. I got out of the water and put my clothes back on, not caring if I got them wet "Maybe next times guys." I said to the mermaids before walking off. I found Peter by the stream with a the look of fear "L-look I kn-know I screwed up this time but- ow, ow, ow, ow, ow!" I grabbed his ear and dragged him back to my hut.

"This is why I don't trust you, you pull off shit like this." I said before yanks his ear out of my hand "Why do you have to be so rough? And you said you couldn't relax? Don't you trust me?" I sigh in disbelief "I thought I told you, you pull off shit like that which at this point I don't even know if I can trust you anymore. And yes I can relax, it's just that I don't wanna have anyone interrupting my privacy. Also I'm rough because that was what I was made to be, Papa wanted to keep me sa-" "Then why did he disown you? If he loved you so much then why did he disown you!?" I look down "I touched a nerve didn't I?" I tackle him to the ground "I knew I should've let bleed to death when I had the chance! But no! I had to stitch your fucking wounds together because of my mother's kindness!" I shouted, I slowly put my hands around his neck "Maybe I should kill you slowly, and bring your body back, maybe dad will accept me!"

Peter Pan's POV
I saw the crazed look in their eyes "Y-Y/N, p-please! Y-y-you don't... have to do this!" they wouldn't listen, their grip tightens around my neck, I was now gasping for air. I could use my knife to get them off me but I don't wanna hurt them! My body then acted on it's own, grabbed them by their shirt and put their lips on mine. I felt the grip on my neck become lighter, but that that didn't matter to me anymore. Instead of choking me they put their arms around my neck, one of my hands on their back and the other was holding their waist. I know this is for grownups but... it felt magical. They deepened the kiss, making making shove my tongue in their mouth, it was what adults called... making out. "Ew!" we heard from behind us. We broke the kiss and saw the lost boys, Tink, and Terence looking at us "It's not what it looks like!" I shout, Y/N shoves me away before getting up and walking away. "Y/N, wait!" that's when they just ran.