I knew I shouldn't be doing this.
I had a boyfriend.
A perfect boyfriend.
A perfect Damon.
All I could think of as I was being touched was Damon. If I just thought about my boyfriend, I could get through this.
"D-Damon." I moaned, continuing to rub and stroke the strange blonde guys penis.
"Babe, that's not my name." He pulled away.
"Try Andi. It'll leave a better taste in your mouth." He smirked.
Andi hooked his index fingers in my lace panties before sliding them off. I felt myself blush and then I slid my hands out of his pants. I watched, my cheeks burning like a fire, as his plaid boxers and his jeans dropped to his ankles. "I'm putting it in whether you want me to or not."
He smirked, and his light blue eyes, sparkled, for a split second, and I felt a tingle in my stomach.
"N-no. Please don't!" I said getting a hold of myself.
I tried to get down but he continued to hold me up.
"Damon. O-Only Damon should be able to do this.." I said.
I shouldnt have done any of this. Why did I let my guard down so easily? Then I remembered. Damon had asked me to come to his house after school and I was sort of hoping we could go all the way, but I guess I couldn't wait that long.
Andi didn't say anything, but he ignored my cries, and inserted his cock inside of me. I screamed in pleasure remembering what pleasure felt like, I gasped. I closed my eyes and pictured that he was damin , running my fingers over his cheeks. I leaned in and kissed him hard, and nibbled his bottom lip. He started thrusting into me and I moaned against his soft lips. "I'll treat you better than Damon ever could, baby." He said as he pulled away.
The blonde kissed my forehead, and then the bathroom door busted open. Andi let me down and we both got dressed again. I couldn't get caught in the boys bathroom. Especially in this situation.
"Audrey!? I know your in here! Are you okay?" Damon's voice echoed through the bathroom, and I felt my heart sink.
He was going to find me and see that I betrayed him. I stayed silent as did Andi, until Damon's footsteps neared. I shuffled behind Andi and rested my head on his back. Then the bathroom stall door swung open revealing a very hurt-looking Damon. I peeked out from behind Andi and Damon's sad expression turned angry.
"What the hell are you doing with my girlfriend? Babe are you okay?" Damon looked at me and I nodded, stepping out from behind the blonde, who happened to be a little taller than my boyfriend.
Damon grabbed my hand and pulled me into a warm embrace. I sighed and pulled away after a bit.
"You." Damon pointed at Andi. "Get out of here now so I can beat your ass. Or I'll just come get your fucking ass." I'd never seen Damon so protective of me.
I didn't know he could be so protective. Andi walked out smirking.
"I regret nothing." Andi smirked, before Damom shoved him against a sink and punched him in the nose. Andi yelped, before kneeing my boyfriend where it hurts. I started crying as they were fighting, because I didn't know what to do. After a few minutes if watching them throw punches back and forth, Andi had Damon trapped. He threw a punch at him, but Damon ducked and Andi hit the wall. I gasped when the wall cracked, and Andi screamed. His knuckles were bloody and he crumbled to the ground. Damon took this chance to start kicking him repeatedly.
"STOP IT! STOP KICKING HIM!" I screamed and tried pushing Damon away from him.
"Leave him alone!" I cried, kneeling down by Andi. I pulled out my cellphone and called an ambulance while Damon growled.
"Damon, you've done enough. Just leave for now." I said, watching as he walked out. Andi looked at me teary-eyed. He croaked out my name, but he winced. I sat there with him, but then he fell unconscious.
****
The ambulance loaded Andi on a stretcher and wheeled him into the truck. This last day had been horrible.
"Who are you?" One of the guys asked me.
"I'm Andi's girlfriend."
"Want to ride with him?" He asked.
I can't believe I lies about being his girlfriend. I was already taken. Isn't this like ... Cheating ?
I shook my head. "I'll just follow you to the hospital."
Special thanks to beebs @rottingaway we brainstormed this and she wrote it ❤ much love for my besfriend. Go follow her she's really given me inspiration . comment #teamdamon or #teamandi I'd like your opinions it could change the story around thanks for reading :D
