When Jeff the Killer met Offenderman (lemon)

Reward

The footsteps came closer and closer, until...: «Jeff, tell me why you are in my office, and under my desk for that matter», Slender commands. «Well, I-... Because I wanted to surprise you, of course!», Jeff lies. «Suprise me with what exactly...?», Slenderman asks in a suspicious tone. «A-... Ehh- Uhm, a blowjob...? Yeah, a blowjob while you do your office-stuff. You've seemed so stressed lately, so I wanted to help out...», Jeff says out of panic and smiles nervously. He hated himself for not being able to come up with a better excuse, but then again he was somewhat curious about how big Slender is compared to his older brother. If they are anything alike, Jeff is in for a rough time. Slenderman was quiet for a bit, before saying: «You still broke a rule; entering my office without permission. You need to be punished accordingly. Giving me a blowjob is a reward». «But- I'm already grounded? I can't go out killing, isn't that the worst punishment there is?», Jeff asked nervously. Slenderman simply chuckled and said: «No, I think I have the perfect punishment for you...». The young killer had no idea what it could be. Slenderman grabbed his hoodie and pulled him up from under the desk. Jeff stood up straight. Slender bent down so he was in Jeff's heigh and unzipped the killer's pants, before pulling them down along with his boxers. Jeff's eyes widened and he could not believe that Slender was most likely about to fuck him in the ass. Jeff tried not to get an erection. «Bend over the desk», Slender commanded as he undid his black leather belt. Jeff slowly walked over to the desk, bending down far, almost laying over it with his upper body. Slenderman held the belt in his hand and whipped Jeff's ass with it. «Ah!», Jeff squirmed in surprise and pain. He was prepared for something else. Slender ignored the boy's scream as he spanked him again, even harder. Once more, then again, and again and again. Harder for every swing. Jeff's eyes teared up. He couldn't hold it in anymore. «Ahh-! Please s-stop, Slendy!», Jeff cried out. Slenderman continued spanking the boy. Jeff's ass was deep red already. Tears were streaming down Jeff's face. Slenderman spanked him around ten more times before picking the boy up, walking over to his office chair, and laying the killer on his stomach over Slender's lap. Jeff sobbed quietly as Slender gently rubbed the red and hot area with his right hand. It was painful and comforting at the same time. «It will be over soon», Slenderman reassured Jeff, who tried to dry off the tears in his face with his hoodie-sleeve. Slender spanked Jeff around 20 times, ignoring Jeff's sobbing screams. «S-Slendy, if you continue I'll pass out...», Jeff said slowly in a raspy voice. His ass was a deep shade of red, along with blue bruises starting to form. Slenderman gently patted Jeff's butt, then helped him sit up on his lap. Jeff looked away, blushing. His eyes were red from crying. Slenderman slowly undid Jeff's hoodie-strings, causing the hood to fall down, revealing Jeff's throat. «Offender?», Slenderman simply asked as he examined Jeff's throat. Jeff shook his head and said: «no, Laughing Jack...». «Oh, I didn't know you liked him», Slenderman said. «I don't. It just happened. I was the one topping him though, kinda nice to be in charge for a change», Jeff explained and shrugged. «Yeah, I picture you as more of a dominant guy. But I'm guessing you have zero control when you're with Offender?», Slender asked. Jeff blushed a little at his comment and nodded slowly. «Was that too personal? I'm sorry», Slenderman said and gently ruffled the boy's hair. «Nonono, it's fine. It's just that I haven't really talked about stuff like this with anyone before», Jeff said in a shy voice and smiled a little at Slender, who patted the boy's back and hugged him. As Jeff hugged him back, the butterfly-knife he had hidden in his hoodie fell to the floor. Jeff gave Slender a nervous smile. Slenderman slowly picked it up and handed it to Jeff. «You can have it back, but be more careful this time. Also, you're not grounded anymore», Slenderman said and patted the boy's head. «Wait, really? Thank you!», Jeff said as he hugged him one more time. «You should probably put your pants on now. Let me know when you want your reward...», Slenderman said and lifted Jeff off his lap. Jeff got dressed and walked towards the door.

As he opened it, he heard «ow-» from the other side of the door. He looked down and it was Ben who he had hit in the head with the door. He had been listening the whole time. Ben stood up. «Soo, did you get my Gamebo-», Ben was cut off by Jeff saying «run» with an intense look on his face and taking out his knife. He had been spanked to the point of almost passing out over a Gameboy that wasn't even his. It was time for the black-haired killer to have some fun too. Ben panicked as he saw the look on the taller boy's face and quickly ran. When he got outside, he slowed down a bit, thinking Jeff couldn't follow him out due to him being grounded. That was not the case anymore. Jeff sprinted after him and tackled the short boy to the ground, and before Ben could tell what just happened, Jeff was on top of him and laughed playfully as he swung his butterfly knife only a few inches from Ben's face. Ben just stared at him for a second before saying: «nice hickeys» and giggling. «Oh yeah? You should see my ass», Jeff joked and rolled over to the side, laying beside Benny. «I believe you, it really sounded like you were dying», the elf-looking boy said. «And yes, I got your Gameboy by the way», Jeff said and handed it to him. «Yay! I love you!», it suddenly slipped out of Ben's mouth, before he blushed and covered his mouth. «Wh-wha...?», Jeff said and looked at him. «Did he mean that? Is he in love with me? Do I like him back?», Jeff thought to himself, before Ben added: «...as a friend I mean, of course...», still blushing. «Yeah, I knew you meant it like that of course, ahaha... What else?», Jeff says and laughs nervously, trying to act normal. The painfully awkward situation was thankfully cut short by Sally opening the main door and shouting: «Toby said dinner's ready!». Jeff quickly got up and offered a hand to help Ben up, but he ignored it and got up. They walked inside and sat down next to each other at the dining table. They both finished eating pretty fast, and Jeff asked Ben if he wanted to join him on a killing spree. «No thanks, I think I'll just play video-games tonight...», Ben said and went to his room». Jeff didn't think much of it. He grabbed his knife and practically ran out the door.

Jeff walked for almost an hour, with no signs of any people being near him. «Fucking typical...», Jeff said to himself quietly. He took his AirPods out and decided to listen to Conan Gray, a guilty pleasure of his. Jeff just wandered around in the woods. It was almost pitch black in the thick forest. However, some areas had fewer trees, so the icy-blue moonlight could shine down at him. He suddenly heard a sound behind him. Jeff took out his AirPods and turned around. It was the sound of rustling leaves on the ground. It came from a bush. Jeff grabbed his knife and slowly walked over to inspect it closer. He heard tiny tapping noises. «Okay this can't be a person at least», Jeff thought to himself, sitting down on his knees. Something came out of the bush. It was a small hedgehog! «Aww, you're so cute...», Jeff whispered softly. He slowly and gently tried to pet it's back with his finger, but it curled up into a pointy little ball. «You remind me of my best friend, Ben; small, cute, and easily scared. He would've liked you. I should take a picture of you before I head back», Jeff told the hedgehog, who was no longer curled up. It just stood there while Jeff had a conversation with it. Jeff smiled at the hedgehog before pulling out his phone and said «say cheese», then taking the picture. «I gotta go now, though. Bye, stay safe, Ben...», the boy said as he stood up and headed back to the mansion.

As Jeff entered the mansion, he saw Ben, Slenderman, and LJ sit on the couch in the living room. «No people today?», LJ asked when Jeff came in, considering the fact that Jeff was not covered head to toe in fresh blood as usual. Jeff shook his head and said: «but, I did find someone, who I named Ben...». You named a corpse after me? Wow, how thoughtful, Jeff», Ben said sarcastically. «No, not a corpse. This guy-», Jeff said and handed Ben his phone with the picture of the hedgehog. «He is so cute... Why did you name him after me?», Ben asked curiously. «Well, like you said he is cute, so it just reminded me of you...», When Ben tried to zoom in on the picture, he accidentally swiped to the right, showing the second-last picture Jeff had saved on his phone. Ben blushed heavily and just stared at the screen. Jeff thought Ben was blushing because Jeff had called him cute. LJ wanted to see the hedgehog too, so he looked over Ben's shoulder. «Oh shit», LJ simply said, with wide eyes. «Do you like it?», Jeff asked eagerly and smiled. LJ bursts out laughing, realizing Jeff doesn't know what just happened or what Ben's actually looking at. Slender gets interested in what's going on. «Let me see», Slender says and takes the phone out of Ben's hand, who is still speechless and red. Slender doesn't say anything, just smirks at Jeff and hands him his phone back. Jeff is confused and looks down at his phone. That wasn't a hedgehog! It was the dickpic he took earlier! Jeff blushes at first, but then just laughs it off. He was proud of his 8-inches, and LJ and Slenderman had already seen it before anyway. Ben on the other hand was probably not expecting that. Jeff tried not to laugh as he asked Ben: «so, what do you think?». Ben looked at him and giggled, still red, but managed to say: «I-... We should make that foursome we talked about earlier, happen...~». «Wait, how am I a part of this foursome? I can't remember discussing that», Slenderman said confused. «We played truth or dare, and I asked Jeff who in this mansion he would fuck, and he said he would have a foursome with, well, us», Ben explained. Jeff nodded and grinned. «Besides, I still want my reward from earlier», Jeff says and bites his bottom lip playfully. Slenderman sighs and says: «Okay, I guess we're actually gonna do this». «Tomorrow after breakfast?», Jeff suggests. LJ and Ben nod. «My bedroom then? I think that's the only bed that will fit us all. Just don't tell anyone about this», Slender warns. «Yeah», LJ says. «Can't wait», Jeff says and smirks, before heading to his bedroom. He completely undresses and falls asleep quickly.