Mafia boss stole my heart (Billdip)

Dipper

(Dipper pov)

I am not usually one to have irrational fears since everything has a rational reason, but I am also afraid of the dark for no rational reason. Like sleeps with hall light and nightlight on afraid. So you can probably imagine my fear when that man left me in this room, handcuffed to a stupid chair and gagged, and turned the lights off leaving me in complete darkness. I struggled trying to get free for a good half hour before giving up, trying not to hyperventilate from fear. I tried to think of anything besides the darkness surrounding me. Like how that man was fucking terrifying as he sang I can't Decide. I usually love that song but him singing it kind of made me not like the song that much anymore. I don't know when I fell asleep but I wake up to the creaking of the metal door. I wake up and see light streaming in through the open door. At first I think the blonde man came back but as I look more closely I see it's the guy with blue hair and he's holding a red plastic cup in one hand with a blue bendy straw. He comes up to me and sets the cup on the table. He reaches towards me and I flinch, a muffled whimper escaping my lips. "I-It's okay. I promise I'm not going to hurt you." He takes the gag out of my mouth so it's hanging around my neck again.

"W-Who are you?" I ask my voice trembling with fear.

"I'm Will. I'm sorry if my brother hurt you, he just doesn't really like liars and he likes to creep people out."

"Wait, that guy is your brother?" Now that he mentions it, they do both look really alike.

"Y-Yeah...anyway I thought you would be thirsty." I nod my head yes so he holds up the cup with the straw pointing at me.

"Seriously? A bendy straw?" I look up at him with a raised eyebrow.

"I like using them. They make me feel like a little kid again." Damn this guy is really childish. I begins drinking from the straw, only now noticing how insanely dry my throat was. Soon I drink every ounce of water from the cup so he sets the cup on the table.

"Th-thank you."

"No problem." He turns to leave.

"Wait please don't!" He turns back to me confused. "P-Please don't leave me in here alone and in the d-dark again...." I feel tears stinging my eyes. He slowly walks back towards me.

"You're afraid of the dark, aren't you?" I give a small nod yes. "Why?"

"Because why not? There is so much to fear about the dark."

He opens his mouth to say something but stops when he hears a voice from the doorway. "What the fuck are you doing in here?" He turns and I see the blond man standing in the doorway, not looking happy. I notice Will tenses up.

"N-nothing....I just thought he was thristy so I brought him some water...."

The blonde man walks up to him putting both hands on Will's shoulders. "I know you want to be kind to everyone, but when I tell you to stay upstairs, then stay upstairs. Understand?" Will gives a small nod yes and the blonde man pats him on the head. "Good. Now head upstairs for me." Will heads out the door and up what sounds like wooden creaky stairs. The blonde man then turns to look at me. "What did he tell? Don't bother lying to me because I know he had to tell you something so just give me the truth."

"He said you two are brothers and that's it I swear." I look up at him trembling in fear.

"Hm." He looks to the table picking up a knife that would be used to cut vegetables. I tense up as he comes towards me with the knife and shut my eyes tightly expecting him to hurt me wtih it. "Open your eyes. I'm not going to hurt you." I slowly open my eyes and see him cut the gag off so it falls to the floor. He gently holds my face in his hand and makes me look up at him, his thumb rubbing the bruise on my cheek making me wince. "I'm sorry I hit you so hard and multiple times on the same cheek, I just hate liars." Wait, did this guy actually apologize for hitting me but not for anything else like kidnapping me? What the fuck?