Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios

When He Tries To Come Back...

©Payton Mikel 2015

Jeff:

You were completely devastated when you saw Jeff and that other girl, who is now dead thanks to you. But you didn't give a shit, he deserved it, and so did she for messing with a killer's girlfriend.  You were a mess without Jeff, you missed him hold in  you, kissing you, and just adoring you.  You missed him, so much.  When your doorbell rang you were surprised to see Jeff. 

  "Y/N, please take me back.  That girl meant nothing to me!" He cried out at you.  His words pulled at your heart, but you stared at him with a blank expression on your face.

  "Go away Jeff." You said softly, holding back tears you slammed the door in his face and walked away, with silent tears running down your face. 

       

            Ben:

  "Y/N! Open the door, please!" Ben sobbed, you glared at the door and flipped it off.

  "Never! You're a cheating son of a bitch!" You screamed at him with angry tears streaming down your face.  "Never come back here, you bastard!" You screamed again and stormed to your room.  You saw a picture of you and Ben on your dresser, you started to break down and cry.  You missed him terribly.

   

           Slender:

   You felt Slender teleport next to you and wrap his tentacle around your waist, you pushed him off.

  "What don't you get by 'we are done' Slender?"  You glared up at the faceless man.  He looked down at you and tilted his head.

  "My love, Alice came at me. I had no intention of doing anything with her at all, as you saw, my arms weren't touching her at all." He said calmly, you recalled the memory, he's right.  Oh shit, you blushed and looked at him.

  "Let me think about this, okay?" You told him and he nodded, then disappeared.

     

           Silver:

    Silver visited you everyday, it was nice to know he still cares.  But your heart still hurt from him cheating.  You sat down with him and told him how you felt.

  "I understand, I'm sorry." He murmured without stuttering, he got better at that.  You hugged him briefly ad smiled slightly.

  "Let me think things through, then come back." You told him, he smiled and ran off.

             E.J:

   You found a kidney in the shape of a heart on your bed, ew.  You looked at the bloodied note under it and smiled.

  Y/N,
       I'm sorry for breaking  your heart, I'm sorry for messing up, I'm sorry for letting you go, I'm sorry for everything I've ever done wrong to you.  I'll let you think about it, but I still love you.
                                                                 Come back to me? Love, E.J
  You smiled and let tears run down your face, you knew the answer you would give him.

             Sonic:

  Sonic came through your computer screen, when he stood up you saw that he was skinnier, his eyes held only desperation, and he held himself together with his arms.  You felt sadness for him for a moment, then rage because he was the one who cheated.  He muttered something and you cocked your eyebrow at him confused.

 

  "I'm sorry, I-I didn't mean yo hurt you so much..." He looked down and sniffed.  He was broken, you knew that already.  You tilted your head to the side and sighed, he looked up with hope in his eyes.

  "Get out of my house, Sonic." You sighed and walked away, you heard muffled cries.  And then they were gone.

 

       Hoodie:

  He crawled in your window, he collapsed and hugged your waist.  You were still beyond pissed at him, he kissed your thigh softly and stood up.

 

  "I'm so sorry." He apologized and started to walk away, you wanted to hug him so badly, but held back and watched him go.

      Masky:

  "Have you made up your mind?" He asked you softly, you were still hurt and you shook your head no.  He nodded and hugged you lightly, you almost gave in and hugged him back.

  A/N: Hello!! I'm sorry I've been a terrible person and nit post in awhile, but... I've had some problems lately.  But I'm fine! So no worries, I'll update soon!! And the song explains so much xD!! Thank you!