Select All
  • I want you to be Mine and Mine only||Ticci Toby x Reader
    122K 3.1K 31

    "You kidnapped me...you killed Chris...You tried to take advantage of me...I know you as the bad guy I've been seeing for the past week. But I dont think I can love you... " Is it possible to love someone as cold and crazy as Toby Rogers? Will you be able to? Or will you keep reminding yourself of what he's done? Sti...

    Mature
  • The New Creepypasta (Hiatus For Rewrite)
    244 7 17

    A lonely but brave girl discovers an abandoned mansion with traces of insanity. Will she restore it into the madhouse of killers it was once rumoured to be? Or will things prove to be too complicated? (I hate past me)

    Mature
  • Jeff x Reader x Ben
    37.8K 1.2K 24

    The title says it all

    Mature
  • This Isn't Love (Homicidal Liu x Reader ) [ONGOING]
    106K 2.9K 29

    "Why would you do this to me? Didn't you say you love me?" "Of course I do love you, you shouldn't have doubted my love for you." "Then why imprison me? Then why violate me? Then why torture me like this?" "Isn't it obvious? Because I love you." He smiled, hands lovingly stroke your pale bruised cheek, eyes passionate...

  • Your Mine, Only Mine. (Homicidal Liu X Reader)
    369K 8.2K 21

    You were the girl always getting picked on. The loner, the unpopular one, the worthless one. You always thought to yourself as human trash. Worthless.. Until one day, you saw him and met him. The one that helped you. Your friend or maybe that's what you thought. And that "him" was Homicidal Liu. (Update 08/10/2019: wh...

  • Normal // A Ticci Toby x Reader Story
    979K 30.5K 40

    Ehhhhh I'll write a description later

  • Misunderstandings // A BEN Drowned x Reader Story
    825K 27.6K 52

    (Y/N) (L/N) was always a fan of creepypasta. She wasn't necessarily crazy obsessed with it, but she found the stories interesting. Sure she had pondered the idea of them actually existing but that just seemed crazy, like something that'd only happen in a book. However, one night she receives a visitor she was never ex...

  • Homicidal Liu x reader
    544K 18.9K 97

    "You, it can't be true. You're alive?" she paused. "How can this be true, you died. Everyone died that day! You can't be alive" The boy just looked at her with no emotions, his eyes grazing over hers. "Believe it, I'm alive and well. Just tell me where he is" She took a step back and whispered to herself, "You can'...

    Completed  
  • That Smiling Idiot (Jeff the killer x reader)
    484K 14.7K 62

    Y/n is a popular serial killer with the catch phrase 'close your eyes and say goodbye', when she take the throne of most popular serial killer Jeff hunts her down. Will their rivalry turn into love? Or will they continue to try and kill each other? Highest ranks I've ever been: #1 creepypasta #1 jeffthekillerxreader...

  • Make You Beautiful - [Jeff the Killer x reader]
    513K 16.8K 41

    [COMPLETED] "There's something I just have to do. Remember that incident with BEN?" I frowned and slowly nodded my head. "Well, I need to make sure something like that never happens. I need to make sure that everyone knows that you're mine." He smirked and took a knife that was on a night table next to the bed. "Ho...

    Completed   Mature
  • Until Death Do Us Part
    43.7K 1.3K 26

    It was one of those nights, I couldn't take the fighting and like normal decided to sneak out to the woods and just walk. But this time, somebody followed me. A boy with a big smile and a white sweatshirt, who would soon become my closest friend and my closest enemy. He saved me and changed my life forever. His name...

    Completed  
  • the Confusion of love. (eyeless jack x reader x jeff the killer)
    32.1K 747 18

    your best friends with eyeless jack but don't know it until that fateful day. from then on your life becomes a tangled mess going along with its pleasant ups and its unwelcome downs that are part of life. tangled in the world of creepypasta you find love in two different men but don't know who to choose and give your...

  • Cruelest Of Hearts~Eyeless Jack X Reader
    390K 13K 49

    When the person you love most is violently taken away from you, you set out on a dangerous journey to find out what happened to him, making your life goal to discover the truth. What you don't expect though, is to uncover secrets that come out of the darkest abyss, accompanied by a cannibalistic creature with a navy-b...

    Completed   Mature
  • Trick And Kill~~Jeff The Killer X Reader X Eyeless Jack
    848K 26K 77

    How much can a human take before the reality around him snaps? For you it was the most unbearable loss of them all. It was more than enough to drown everything sane inside of you. The monster rose inside of you and everything went up to flames. But you are not alone. Madness knows no limits. The same goes for love.~~...

    Completed   Mature
  • Wolf & Pig (Eyeless Jack x Reader)
    525K 18.2K 30

    "That's right. I am the big bad wolf. You are the little piggy" He licked his lips "I can eat you up whenever I want..." ---------------------- I met him at McDonalds. He order a lot of food that he claimed was for his friends, but I didn't believe a word he said I fell hopelessly in love with him. Then he tried to k...

    Completed   Mature
  • Ticci Toby X Reader
    2.1M 68.6K 60

    Just a simple party with friends can trigger something deep inside of you but this may attract certain attention.

    Completed  
  • Camp Creepypasta (Ticci Toby x Reader)
    1.4M 46.9K 33

    Slendy needs more Creepypastas. So he takes Splendy's advice and makes a summer camp to train some chosen kids to become Creepypastas. He sends out letters to the chosen kids to tell them that they have been chosen. You live with your little brother and abusive father. What happens when you get one of the letters and...

    Completed  
  • Sins [Jeff the killer x reader]
    136K 3.9K 19

    Jeff attempts to kill you, but you almost kill him instead. [abandoned]

  • Carved Happiness ( Jeff the Killer x reader )
    405K 11K 43

    This is by no means a story of which a girl falls in love with this amazing, hot serial killer who is so protective of her in the slender mansion. This is twisted story. A story of gore and sociopathy details that gives the real meaning of Jeff the killer, a mad man who barely feels anything who somehow feels a slithe...

    Completed  
  • Chains: Eyeless Jack X Reader
    3.7M 139K 57

    I didn't write this but I have been given permission to post this all credit goes to Valentinesdaygreen and a link below to the original story origin http://valentinesdaygreen.deviantart.com/

    Completed