What if James and Lily Potter were hiding something about Lily's pregnancy? What if Harry had a twin that no one knew about? What if Voldemort tried went to the Potter residence to kill both kids that night? What if the two twins have the same scar, just in different places? What if...the twins were in different Hogwarts houses? Phoenix Minerva Potter is the youngest Potter twin that survived that one fateful night. When she ends up at Hogwarts one night, Professor Dumbledore realizes that she has practiced magic, somewhere and somehow, but she hasn't been sorted in a house. That night, she gets sorted. Everyone knows what to expect, and the Sorting Hat has the same conflict with the youngest twin that it did with the eldest. The answer shocks everyone. DISCLAIMER: I DO NOT OWN ANY OF THE HARRY POTTER CHARACTERS. THESE CHARACTERS BELONG TO THE WONDERFUL J.K. ROWLING.