Twenty-something Alexa Ryan and her stable boyfriend Carter are slowly building a life together and after three years, Alexa's ready to take their relationship to the next level. She's dropped multiple painfully obvious hints, and much to her dismay, Carter seems just fine with how things are right now. Beau Wyatt is a businessman who's work brings him to Alexa's new town and into her path, but not for the first time in their lives. Thanks to Alexa's college years, this tall, dark, and handsome specimen of a man waltzed into her life and made a lasting impact on her heart and emotions. A freak accident causes Alexa to begin imagining what her life could be like with either of the two men standing in front of her, asking for her heart. With no shortage of trouble or shenanigans along the way, Alexa must ultimately make a heart-breaking decision - but one that may be best for her.