Several years after moving to San Francisco for a fresh start, home interior designer Noelle Clark returns to her hometown of Silverwood Falls for the holidays. While there, she runs into her old high school flame, Nicholas Richards, the man who broke her heart and sent her fleeing to the west coast. Feelings Noelle had long since repressed are rekindled, and she finds herself falling in love with Nicholas all over again. Could this Christmas bring tidings of joy for Noelle, or will she be left heartbroken a second time?