@Cicada3300 .... he’s basically saying you’re both operating outside the comfort-driven mainstream lane good for you.. there is more than enough corpo sludge., and he’s specifically contrasting your work against big commercial “easy entry” books like The Hunger Games, Harry Potter, Fifty Shades, that kind of structurally accessible storytelling.
And then the more important part, the part that actually matters to me is his reaction .. . That he’s noticing: the entry points, the deeper payoff y And then going further and saying he sees your writing as stronger than those mass-market hype pushed money machines in terms of depth and motive execution.
That’s not a genre comparison at all. That’s him responding to difficulty plus payoff, which is a very specific kind of reaction. It means he’s engaging with plot
And I think I see why you’re excited. It’s not “someone famous mentioned me.” It’s more like: someone understands combat writing is saying, “I recognize what you’re doing, and I respect the risk you’re taking,... the payoff is real.”
That’s different validation. It’s about craft courage,
don’t get spun off it emotionally though ,
this: statement “better than” top-selling books is always contextual. bud
What it does tell you pretty cleanly is this: your work is not being read as “confusing,” by smart people it’s being read as “demanding but rewarding,” which is actually the category of writing that build s longer-term, readers rather than casual k pop kids and bounce of shallow derps .
cool.. but keep working ..it still needs work
IMO