I’m still reading, but just on first impressions of your story from the first chapter I think it’s a very cute and unique idea. The first chapter is what will grab your audience on here or anywhere else really. I think you have a great story idea, especially since it’s a true story.
For the first chapter, I think the first half of it could use a bit more elaboration. Possibly a story of what your friends and you did or about your sister punching the other kid bigger than her and then you being scared of her. It may make the reader see what you’re saying about being the nerdy kid more and then in turn, make the view of your girl seeing you for who you are a bit stronger. It may make it flow a bit more. It isn’t bad though at all.
I never hear about the male point of view so to see this is very cool. I think it gives a totally different perspective than usual. The banter back and forth between you two is cute so far, and the retro throw back feel is a really cool vibe. I also like that you had that crush instantly, like she was meant to meet you in that moment. Very sweet. The only thing about this half is maybe elaboration on how boring things were before she came in. It’ll make you seeing her for the first time pop more in my opinion. That’s it about that though.
That’s my first impression review at least. Take my criticism with a grain of salt. You don’t have to follow my advice at all. I’m just telling you how the parts make me feel as I read them. Don’t change your story too much for people and certainly not for me. Write exactly what you want to write. I just wanted to give you feedback on flow of the story from my reader perspective. Can’t wait to read the rest and give an up to date review!